Well then it's time for you to get with the program.
I've been a recruiter for a long time, but I can only speak from my own experience. You could ask 5 different people those questions and get 5 different answers. YMMV. The answer with a lot of things in the jobsearch process is "it depends".
I'll try to take your questions in order - cover letters. As a recruiter, I don't read cover letters nor do I require applicants to do them. Cover letters are opinion pieces, resumes should be factual documents. I'm interested in facts. A cover letter is never going to make someone who's not a fit for one of my positions be a fit
Some companies do require them and if you're going to apply there, you should do one. When I was in my own last jobsearch, I refused to do them 99% of the time. Especially those "tell us why you're just dying to work here" ones. I haven't interviewed with your company yet, I haven't spoken with anyone on the team yet - I don't know if I'm dying to work there or not - nor do I have the time nor inclination to blow smoke up you butt.
Even experienced jobseekers are easy targets for scams and fake jobs - so please be careful. The scammers have become increasingly sophiscated - creating fake identities, sometimes entire fake companies. If you have a question about whether or not a job or recruiter is real, try to contact the company.
You wrote: ". Where do I start, when there is too much information and opinions on what a resume should look like"
Please see another comment that I wrote last night on another post regarding what a resume should look like and how to please please please use your critical thinking skills when considering "advice". There are a lot of dimfluencers out there preying on vulnerable jobseekers.
You wrote: "how to rewrite everything over and over again"
Unless you are applying for wildly different positions, I see no need to rewrite your resume over and over again. Your experience is your experience. How much can you change the resume. And who has that kind of time - not me. If you
do need to keep rewriting your resume, then you probably need to narrow your search.
You wrote: "to get the keywords correct to bypass the HR apps"
That is not how it works. I'll warn you right now - you will hear tons of lies about this particular issue. Most of the dimfluencer "experts" spouting off about this topic have never worked in an ATS a day in their life. I have been using them since they became commercially available.
I have experience with 8 or 9 different ATS and with different configurations of those systems.
What an ATS does is right there in the name - Applicant TRACKING System. It's where you apply to positions.
The ATS is basically an electronic filing cabinet that stores resumes, allows recruiters to manage and track candidates through the interview process, it’s where offer letters are generated.
There typically is no sorting involved with the application process – and sorting is where keywords come in.
Here's what happens (on all the systems I've ever used) when a candidate applies to one of my open requisitions:
I click on their name in the list of new applicants for that requisition. Their resume has not been ranked. It has not been sorted for keywords. It has not been "scored". It has not been filtered.
I click "download resume". It downloads in whatever format - Word doc or PDF - the candidate uploaded it. I look at their resume. With my eyeballs. Every one.
There's no need for me to search or sort by keywords - or anything else - for new applicants because you're sitting right there in the list of new applicants.
Searching happens if I want to search the database for previous applicants, and is completely separate from the application process.
Keywords are just skills or experience that we use in our search strings to find candidates (which is different than applying). Ideally, they should just be an organic part of a resume. Loading your resume up with words you think recruiter or hiring managers want to see may get someone to click on your resume, but if the experience isn't there, it doesn't matter how many "key words" you stuff your resume with.
Probably the single biggest complaint recruiters get from hiring managers is "this resume is stuffed with keywords but doesn't tell me anything about the person's actual experience".
And no matter how many times those dimfluencers tell you otherwise, the ATS is not making decisions about applicants.
I know most candidates don't seem to want to hear this, but when you're being rejected, you're being rejected by a human.
I'm the bot.
There is an entire industry that has grown up around trying to separate jobseekers from their money. Many try to use fear - if you don't pay for me to re-write your resume or pay $5,000 for my secret sauce coaching course, you'll never find a job.
Many of these dimfluencers have zero qualifications to be dishing out jobsearch advice. They have no recent recruiting experience, no experience as a hiring manager. Are there good job coaches and resume writers - yes, but most people don't need a job coach and most people can write their own resume. There is tons of FREE content out there - resume template, interview help, etc.
I recommend you follow people like Amy Miller and Kristen Fife on LinkedIn - they're both long time, experienced recruiters. Amy has a YouTube channel with tons of free content and Kristen has published over 100 articles for jobseekers - also all free.
You wrote: "or is now what I heard on a broadcast, that resumes and apps no longer work, that you must have friends and colleagues in a company to get a job now, that only connections work?"
Also not true. Networking is great. Referrals are awesome. You should definitely be networking and asking for referrrals. But applying absolutely works too.
The vast majority of the positions I've filled in the last 3 1/2 yrs have been from people who either applied or who I sourced.
A small percentage were from networking or referrals. Every company had a referral bonus program in place and I also ask for referrals. The number of referrals that were hires throughout a 20+ year recruiting career is also very small.
If companies were able to fill the majority of their positions by networking, they would not need to employ the teams of recruiters and sourcers and outside agencies who spend all day, every day working to fill their positions.
Not to use you as an example, Anonymous - but FGBers - please don't put yourself in this position. The best job security you can have is an up-to-date resume and a well-tended network.
Please let me know if you have any questions. I know this is a really scary time to be a Federal employee and all my good thoughts are going your way.
Good Luck on your journey!!
Share your insight
Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.
19 Comments
Join the conversation