I made it to a third interview and they want me to send them a video of why I want to work at the company.
Being from HR this is so not ok - it can open the door to discrimination. Thoughts on how I should reply?
4
10 Comments
10 Comments
Karleen Leveille
61
I want all women to WIN
01/26/21 at 10:11PM UTC
First - you are right. This is a very valid concern. The question is do you want to work for a company that does not consider the consequences of instituting this type of evaluation. You can address via an email by posing it as you want to protect them by not engaging in an illegal hiring practice. As a compromise, offer something else like a PowerPoint deck that you narrate and aren't on camera or offer to send them voice memo/podcast discussing your interest in their company.
User edited comment on 01/26/21 at 10:21PM UTC
1
2 Replies
Lisa
90
Employee Communications and HR Specialist
01/26/21 at 10:20PM UTC
Thank you! I agree.
1
Reply
Cinzia Iacovelli
473
Marketing Project Manager, Digital Events
01/27/21 at 7:42PM UTC
Is this really an illegal hiring practice? I'm just genuinely curious here.
1 Reply
Anonymous
01/27/21 at 7:48PM UTC
I’m not a lawyer but I am black - and although it may not be illegal to use videos. There are enough studies that show that there is an inherit bias when it comes to black and brown people. Video can increase the bias. So to be clear - video doesn’t discriminate but people do and it just adds one more element of it.
1
1 Reply
Cinzia Iacovelli
473
Marketing Project Manager, Digital Events
01/27/21 at 8:31PM UTC
Thanks for the explanation!
Reply
Maryann Augusta
86
Consultant
01/26/21 at 10:59PM UTC
I’m not sure I understand. How did you make it this far? We’re the interviews via phone? Many companies are doing zoom interviews and some have resumed interviewing in person. How is a video different from these two senarios?
2
Reply
Anonymous
01/27/21 at 12:03AM UTC
Strange but video is video I'm assuming since you can record zoom meetings pretty easily.
I do think this request is a bit odd that it gives you the chance to edit, rehearse and otherwise prepare to put your best face forward as it were.
I've not heard of this before but with do many people creating content these days I guess it's a novel approach.
1
Reply
Anonymous
01/27/21 at 1:08AM UTC
The last time I was in job search mode, was in 2018. In just a brief time, and certainly accelerated by the pandemic, the interview process has changed.
Recording a video is right up there with self-branding and being active on LinkedIn. As a Gen Xer, I have been getting myself acquainted with new interview trends by watching YouTube videos on the subject and following people in HR posting content on LI.
Come to find out, pre-recorded videos are being used to apply for college internships and organizations in the tech industry.
Within the last month I was given the option to submit a 30 second "about me" video to be considered for a contract job with Apple. I opted not to submit a video because it was optional and it did not feel right - meaning I was not comfortable doing so. However, I do know that it is an opportunity to stretch my muscles and come up with a compelling "about me" story. On my own time and my own terms, I am working my way to scripting and recording these videos to have available upon requested.
Because you know what, somewhere out there are wonderful souls who are effortlessly recording themselves on video AND getting hired.
1
Reply
Natalia
370
Motivating You Forward
01/27/21 at 5:25AM UTC
Hi, curious as to why this isn't okay? I have seen this request a lot not only for jobs, but programs, cohorts, internships etc. I'm thinking they are asking you to do this because they are having a hard time deciding amongst you and another candidate. Also, this might be a fast way for them to decide versus reading a written answer.
Reply
Krista Haugner Sieg, MBA
367
FairyGodBoss In Training. D & I Advocate.
01/27/21 at 1:15PM UTC
Really interesting issue Lisa! I have a feeling that the person who made the request hasn't even considered how this could open the door to discrimination and/or how even in a high tech world, creating a quick video is an undertaking if you want to get the lighting and all of the other elements right.
Reply
Looking for a new job?
Our employer partners are actively recruiting women! Update your profile today.
The Fairygodboss Feed
We're a community of women sharing advice and asking questions