One Bad Moment Results in 3 Months of Remedial EQ Training 1.5 Years Later

First, let me tell you about the incident in question. I had been at my new job for about 6 months. My colleague went out-of-state unexpectedly, during our department's first ever mock interview event, and I offered to cover for her. She had done all the work, I just needed to greet alumni employers and get them set up in rooms to meet with students.

The morning of the event, I came down with the flu and all but one volunteer disappeared. That one volunteer let me know that although we had signs on the reserved rooms, there was a group of people in one room and the alumni employer and student were outside waiting. Our mock interviews were only 30 minutes long, so every minute lost mattered. She asked if I could help. So, I took the reserved sign off the door and turned it so the folks inside could see it and tapped the glass.

Little did I know the firestorm this would cause. The group was holding a real professional interview. One of the women inside told her supervisor that I had been unprofessional and had given a terrible impression to the potential employee, who did not take the job. Her supervisor told my supervisor, who told me to write a formal apology. Which I did.

I find it curious that no one seemed concerned about the impression on the alumni employer or student who had been kept waiting and it didn't seem to matter that their interview had exceeded its time into another department's event.

Fast forward 1.5 years to my first formal evaluation. I had read an article just that morning about how men were evaluated on their work and women were evaluated on their personality.

For the record, out of 3 goals, I had nearly doubled one goal, over tripled another from 15% to 52%, but fell short on the third goal. In my first year, I only saw 42% of my assigned students, instead of 50% . Although I missed goal by 8%, I was still over 20% higher than the national four-year cumulative average, in my first year, with a caseload 20-40% heavier than the others in my department. In other words, it was a tough goal, I did my best, and I'm not ashamed of my performance.

Despite 2 of the 3 goals being significantly exceeded, they were listed as 'Met' and "Partially Met'. My supervisor stated, "I suppose I should put 'Exceeded,' instead of 'Met' on this one. You did nearly double it." I agreed, but then realized he wasn't actually offering to change it. Wait, and what about the one I over tripled? It wasn't even mentioned.

Then came the assignment of new goals: 3 months of emotional intelligence activities to improve professional relationships with colleagues and employers. (In fact, nearly every goal had relationship building as the rationale.) I specifically asked if this had to do with that ONE incident a year and a half ago? He said, "Yes." He didn't want me to be "defined by it in the future." I asked if he felt I had been defined by it? He repeated that he didn't want me to be. It's a small campus culture.

When I tell others they laugh and tell me this is completely ridiculous. One former director wrote me a letter of recommendation, without me asking, to help with my first EQ goal of gathering feedback. In it she stated, that when inevitable drama happens, I have always been part of the solution. She also offered to recommend me to her current company.

In all previous jobs, I have 'exceeded expectations' overall, earning promotions and a stellar reputation. Honestly, as a former manager and director, if my employee only had one complaint in nearly two years, I would celebrate the accomplishment.

So, was that article right? Was I being judged on my personality, rather than my work, because I'm a woman?

Also, I'm curious. If I had sexually harassed someone, would the punishment be less than window tapping?

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

11 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Anonymous

    I don’t think that your evaluation was fair, in that you significantly exceeded 2 goals and missed the third narrowly— despite a workload that exceeded those of your peers. You sound tremendously competent and energetic.

    On the other hand, you need to restore trust with your current manager/department or move on to a better setting. That might mean completing the EQ work or seeking greener pastures.

    There is another area that you might reflect upon. What are your day-to-day relationships like with your colleagues, and is there room for improvement? The reason that I ask is that your manager seems concerned about your EQ, which would seem to relate to more than one incident. Is there anything you should be doing differently?

  2. Anonymous

    I appreciate your feedback.

    Honestly, I don't mind doing the EQ activities. I volunteered to take the training before the evaluation, because I always wish to improve, my background is in counseling, and I'm always looking for more information in my field. If it hadn't been phrased as a punitive action attached to that one incident, and simply been professional growth, I wouldn't have an issue. I fully intend to complete it, because we all have blind spots.

    This workplace has a siloed culture. People generally are here to do their work and there are very few interactions between departments. My department is tiny, but we care and support each other. It has taken a lot of getting used to coming from more inclusive settings.

    This also might have been the result of my supervisor's new boss asking him to find things for me to improve upon and it was certainly the lowlight. Not having a lot of negatives, it does shine brightly. It was just handled badly.

  3. Barbara Hyatt

    Precisely ZERO% of my performance reviews with the company I've been with for the last 6 months have been about my work. They have all been about my personality ("I need you to smile more, you need to make yourself more approachable, you need to be softer"). And I work for a major international staffing firm. So I would say that there is at least SOME truth to the article.

  4. Anonymous

    I remember training myself to smile to appear more approachable when I was in junior high school. I grew up in a tourist town and customer service was the top job skill. My feet may be bleeding from these heels, but you would never know it from my face.

    There was a study about LinkedIn profile pictures and whether or not smiling mattered to employers/recruiters. I think you already know the answer. If you are a woman, smiling made a positive difference. For men, it wasn't as great of a difference, as long as you still appeared professional.

    I believe there was also a study related to gender and YouTube videos that mentioned a similar result. There is a cultural expectation that trains us to behave in a particular way to receive positive attention from our society. If you violate this... well, you know.

  5. Explorer887952

    You definitely weren’t evaluated fairly, and I’d make sure the person above them knows it. Or bring it to HR’s attention along with the multitude of articles demonstrating the known bias against women during performance reviews, and that it’s obvious people in your org need to undergo training to undo said bias.

    I was let go from my previous role because the “optics” on me taking a mental health day was not liked by my team. I hadn’t missed one single day of work. Put in 50+ hours a week for 3.5 months before taking a day off. In that time, every coworker (male) on my team would regularly leave early for golfing with their parents, birthday parties, vacations, 3 week trips to Asia, etc. I took *one* day. I should have said I had a physical illness - then I might have been taken seriously.

  6. Anonymous

    Yikes! I think it's because we put in so much effort in being conscientious workers that it hurts so much when we are confronted with the double standard.

  7. Balanced357247

    OK, you were relatively new in the job, and you offered to cover for a coworker at an event that seemed like it was going to be fairly easy. However, things went awry - volunteers left you in the lurch and on top of that, you got the flu. The only other volunteer there apparently wasn't a "take action" person, which left you having to charge.
    Someone had to address those people sitting in the room that was reserved for your event.
    You flipped the sign around to make sure the interlopers in the room knew that the room was RESERVED. Tap, tap. Hello People. Let's get moving here. They ought to be courteous to those who've actually reserved this space.

    At face value, your event was deemed less important over another event that was running over.
    Then what? You had to write an apology letter?!

    Now, if you have thin skin, just stop reading from here. You can go along happy thinking your actions were fully justified. The next part gets hard to digest.

    1. It doesn't matter whether you were right.
    2. It doesn't matter whether your own management believed that you were right.
    3. The message you are being sent is this: you were wrong.

    So where the freak did you go wrong, you ask? It's not what you said, it's *how* you said it. Body language, attitude, demeanor.
    And sometimes merely saying "sorry" isn't enough.

    Why? Because that apology was coerced from you, like a parent grabbing a child by the ear and forcing the words out. So yeah, you apologized, but really, "Not sorry." People can smell if an apology isn't authentic. Especially those in the periphery of your circle who's heard this story a dozen times.

    How differently things would have gone if you had said, "I think I was out of line back there, and I'm really sorry. I wish I would have handled that differently."

    A year and a half ago, your professional slate was tarnished by an incident. The situation should have just blown over, however, 18 months later, you're still receiving feedback on it. That's the telling sign. For you, it was a once and done incident. For everyone else, it was the eye opener to who you are as a person. Now they're watching to see if you've grown, or if you still have some residual crummy attitude.

    And that my friend, is getting to the root of the problem.

    Most companies today are acutely focused on getting the toxicity out of their culture and climate. And rightly so, work performance becomes more secondary.

    The good news is that it sounds like you haven't been demoted, and no one is tossing you out the door yet - probably because you ARE a top performer.
    If management thought you were beyond hope, they could do that, hoping you get disgruntled and look for work elsewhere.
    "Phew, we finally got rid of that rotten apple with the stinky attitude. She was making everyone else here have a nasty attitude too. Glad she's someone else's problem now."

    So if you're still reading this, what do you do? You hit the reset.
    You can find either find a new job and start completely fresh again, OR.... you can stay in the company where your performance is solid and valuable. Use your internal drive to furiously re-set your reputation there. Dive into those emotional intelligence activities with a hunger to transform yourself. Soak up the benefits of that coursework you're being offered with gratitude.

    Learn from this and you can grow in a beautiful direction with grace. 2020 is your opportunity to show that you're willing to change.

    You can do this.

  8. Sharika82

    I like your perspective on this. Great advice.

  9. Fifilarue

    It sounds like you are dealing with a situation where you are considered to have broken an unspoken social rule. This happens all the time, but it's always disproportionately painful because social rules tap into our basic survival instincts and can trigger fight or flight stress responses. Google "psychological safety" or read "No Hard Feelings at Work" for more info.

    I heard a nice example of the odd effect of social rules in a podcast with Dan Ariely. Audience members were reasonably happy to admit to driving while texting but were less happy to admit to not having washed their hands at least once after using the bathroom in the last week. How strange that we feel more uncomfortable admitting to poor hygiene, than risking the lives of others!? We humans are strange creatures!

    Back to your situation - I think you are dealing with social penalties for a minor faux-pas. When you tapped on the glass, I am guessing that you have been seen as somewhat passive-aggressive. Deep down you maybe also think that you were a bit more curt than you would have liked given that you mention the flu/volunteer/time pressures you were under.

    How would you do it differently? Your colleague might possibly have expected you to open the door and respectively request that they leave? However their reaction maybe says more about their dysregulation than you - why have they reacted so badly to this one event? and then raised the issue with several colleagues over time? You may have come over as a bit abrasive, but it does sound like you are paying a disproportionate price based on how you have described the situation.

    The colleague might have been embarrassed by this over-running which might be one explanation for the fuss? Or maybe the interview was already going badly and you are a convenient scapegoat for losing this good candidate? Or maybe their dog died? You can't know, but it does sound like they were stressed about something other than you. Have a listen to Brene Brown's TED talk on Vulnerability.

    Perspective taking doesn't make it any easier though does it? - especially as the effect has lingered on for so long? Something similar happened to me and I was definitely affected by gender bias. A junior employee made a fuss about me after asking for more responsibility and then getting out of their depth. She cried when I wasn't in the office and as a result I was somehow labelled as an unlikeable woman who had made her cry. HR investigated and concluded that I'd not been unreasonable and that she was being immature, but it was impossible to shift the stigma of unlikeabililty that had lodged in my colleagues' minds. I ended up deciding to leave after 2 years working hard on "likeability" and now I can start afresh.

    While trying to learn about this I have met quite a few women who have been considered unlikeable and they are usually very nice and not "toxic" as Balanced357247 implied. They are usually women who have been told to be more confident and speak up during their early career, and they end up in positions of authority because of that advice. Unfortunately what gets you here, won't get you there... and a confident female boss is considered negatively. In my experience the advice about being more confident seems to go out of date in a woman's early to mid-thirties when she is most likely to get promoted and the push-back begins. The female double bind: you can be likeable or competent, but you can't be both.

    You don't mention the gender of the person in interview room when you tapped the glass. It's a close run thing, but I'm going to guess that it was woman - you say that there was a fuss (someone happy to express hurt feelings to colleagues?) and the request for an apology (male colleagues don't seem to think about giving or receiving apologies in my experience).

    I have tended to have more problems and more negative feedback from women when trying to resolve some sort of conflict or performance issue at work. Men might not have been happy with me but they seem to be quieter about it. Women seem to have much more complex social rules and expect women colleagues to be friendly or maternal rather than boss like. The mismatch in personas causes problems. In my case there were a handful of women over a 10 year period who made negative comments about me which were not passed on or lacked sufficient detail to be useful. And I found that once I had had a complaint, there was a tendency for managers/colleagues to notice evidence to support the complaint and overlook evidence to the contrary. So when the junior colleague cried it was further evidence that I was too harsh, rather than her being immature and HR's comments supporting me counted for very little.

    I found that it became a self fulfilling prophecy because people began to treat me in a slightly less friendly way, which meant I was slightly less friendly back.... If I were to do it again, I would put in a lot of effort to overcompensate by being super friendly to everyone!

    I also found the lack of specific and concrete feedback really upsetting as it came down to extremely small details of non verbal body language which are highly subjective and difficult to control.

    Gender bias is a real thing and it does sound like it could be affecting how you are being viewed. When I asked for advice on this I was told that: "women are viewed more negatively in a male dominated workplace and it is probably not you - don't blame yourself for the biases in your environment".

    The fact is that upsetting people is pretty easy and it happens more often as you progress in your career - unless you've been hyjacked by the other side of gender bias double bind (when women are too nice and don't upset people, they don't get promoted in the first place). So we are damned if we do and damned if we don't - with women who are promoted by being successful and good at their jobs being left very vulnerable to attacks on their personality.

    I have been wrestling with the effect of the double bind for quite a while now and I'm upset because it isn't fair. However I've found by experimenting (and comparing notes with other women) that if I take a lot of extra time and effort to explain my thinking and project warmth (lots of smiling and warm eye contact) I don't get as much push-back as before. It is frankly exhausting and it seems very unfair that the guys don't have to put in this sort of effort, but it's either that or suffer from social penalties which do have the potential to de-rail women's careers.

    I do think that Balanced357247's view is rather black and white and I don't believe that you are toxic. Like all of us you are learning and you'll do better next time - don't be so hard on yourself.

    To Balanced357247 - I wish you the best in your career, but if you are as direct in real life as you are in writing, you'll soon be upsetting people and getting a taste of the gender bias double-bind. I hope it doesn't bite you too hard.

  10. Anonymous

    Fifilarue,
    Thank you for your response. I waited until I had processed both your and Balanced's comments, before responding. You also gave me resources, which I wanted to explore.

    When we are young, we are encouraged to be confident in who we are, be brave, speak up, advocate for ourselves, while simultaneously being told that we are prettier if we smile. Then there are hundreds of micro-actions that show us what we are being told as children is not what our culture allows as adults.
    "Be yourself! No, not like that."

    I will admit to Bananced's point, that there was definitely an Anne Shirley apology moment that happened. In other words, it was done more to make amends than to admit that I was solely at fault, but it was well-written and thoughtful. It also came with the realization that whatever I thought was justice, didn't matter to anyone, except me.

    You are right, it was a woman who requested the apology. She responded to it with further direct criticism. I ignored the parts that were not factual and offered to write an apology to the candidate, as well. She stated that despite my actions, she was graciously able to forgive me as long as it never happened again and she was willing to start over from scratch in our relationship, but couldn't assure me that others on her team would feel the same way.

    As reassuring as this is, I learned that I am not psychologically safe in this culture. I am vulnerable to attack from other departments. Choosing not to speak with me directly about the incident and instead going through my supervisor was a message that I am beneath her. There are power dynamics here that, you are right, I stumbled into. Coming from a position of authority in my last organization, I really didn't grasp the political level of my current position and I was put in my place. It is a very lowly place and has taken a lot of re-evaluation of my professional values to adjust.

    I have a lot of social confidence, built over many years of overcoming obstacles. Typically, my new ideas, initiative and capability leads me quickly to promotions, but not here. This is a comfortable position with very little growth potential, that I chose to relieve the pressure on my family caused by working too many hours attempting to spin straw into gold and wondering if the king was going to execute me, despite the pile I'd spun the day before.

    I actually know a lot about toxic cultures, but the role I took was usually to protect my team from facing the worst of it, by using myself as a buffer, because I can take it. Then I decided, I shouldn't have to.

    I don't think the woman who complained saw horns sprouting when I tapped on the window. I think she was appalled that at my audacity. How dare I? Who do I think I am? I think I unintentionally threatened her.

    During our voluntary EQ training the question was asked, "How does your culture feel about emotions?" The answer was, "Fine, as long as they are positive."

    To your experience, I had a male co-worker tell me that his female boss used a label to describe him that followed him for 5 years, even past when she was fired. He never forgave her for how that label stuck and made his professional life that much harder.

    Is EQ in our current business culture being misused to make the employees more superficially harmonious while punishing them for not showing "proper empathy"? It feels like a white-washing of feelings meant to cull behaviors that could actually end up being positive and inspire growth or correction. There should be room for healthy respectful discourse around disagreements.

    Like your situation, sometimes frank and honest discussions can cause perceived negative emotions. I just had a client in tears because I was validating her ability to pursue a more challenging future, because she wasn't allowing herself to recognize her own value. Hopefully, no one saw.

    My habit of wanting to find solutions has always served me well, but I am aware now that this is not currently my role. So, as long as I'm here, I will try not to make waves. I will not suggest changes that may increase anyone's workload or utilize resources. I will make everyone more comfortable by being a little disengaged, politely doing my job in my office, smiling, and not threatening anyone.

    I feel diminished.

  11. Fifilarue

    I’m sorry to hear that. Don’t choose to be diminished. Yes decide to maybe keep a low profile but use the energy you will conserve on your family. In a few years when you’re ready you can get back in the game somewhere else and have a career second wind. It’s ok to have a pause while you have caring responsibilities. Good luck

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members