Gift giving advice?

I started a new job about half way through this year and quickly became very fond of my teammates. As I head back to the Southwest for the holidays, I've decided I want to bring each of them something back and have more or less settled on some brandy from one of my hometown distilleries. Problem is, my boss doesn't drink. Now, it's hard to explain how I feel about this man... He reminds me a lot of my late grandfather, but with less social awareness (my grandfather was very progressive) and more ex-cop (he's a retired two star captain with the NYPD). Until earlier this week, I would have just brought him some nice candy or something, but then on Tuesday he surprised my whole team with a "fieldtrip" to a public holiday concert nearby. I was really touched by what a sweet gesture it was and want whatever I bring back for him to be equally thoughtful. I'm terrible at gift giving, though, and could use some springboard ideas to get me going.