There is a job I am interested in but it's near the bottom of my salary range (it's actually equal to my current salary). They list a 10K salary range and I am already in the middle of that 10K. Being a state job there are no opportunities for bonus, profit sharing, etc.
Would you pass this over? I am looking for something new because my current company is struggling with the financial fallout from COVID and I worry we could go bankrupt but I haven't officially been told that, just that we are under severe financial distress.
2
13 Comments
13 Comments
Cynthia Tiwana
14
01/11/21 at 5:27PM UTC
in
You can negotiate, definitely. The benefits are good, and in my case, I get a 40 hour work week, and it is stable. Yes, I don't get paid top dollar but I don't worry about losing my job. You usually get a COLA every year and as long as you are a good employee, you'll get your increase until you hit the max. Even if you match your current salary, you'll have some peace of mind, which is hard to buy right now.
3
Reply
Lesa Edwards
569
THE career expert for high achievers
01/11/21 at 5:46PM UTC
in
There is room for negotiation within the stated range (they aren't likely to be able to go above that because it might bump you over experienced employees with the same title). Be sure to give compelling reasons as to why you deserve the top of the range (it can't be about your financial situation or any personal situation you are in). Go for it!
2
Reply
Danielle
12
01/11/21 at 6:17PM UTC
in
I was able to negotiate a higher starting step within my grade. But that limits my available step increases in the role that I have. I made the change to the state after working for a private consulting firm. The stability is the biggest win for me, I don't have to find work or clients, the work finds me.
1
Reply
Claudia
278
Current events call for adapting new solutions.
01/11/21 at 6:26PM UTC
in
This depends on the state.
In California, if you have never worked for the state before, there is almost zero wiggle room when coming in to the state.
The hiring manager would have to choose to do a 'hiring above minimum' and match your prior pay, or match +5%, which means you were such the perfect candidate that they have to justify in writing why hiring someone else AT minimum can't accomplish the same thing. I have this issue recently when looking to do a hire.
State govt has a LOT LESS wiggle room for negotiation than private sector jobs. That being said, NEVER bring it up until an offer is made that they want to hire you, because it's probably not even something the hiring manager can negotiate on your behalf. It usually falls to HR to have those discussions independent of the manager.
It's possible, but unlikely, that you can negotiate for different pay. Don't hold your breath on it. But definitely ask! You never know.
3
2 Replies
Anonymous
01/11/21 at 6:36PM UTC
in
In most cases I would agree with not bringing it up until later but in the past year I have started to ask for range if not published and also comp package value. The reality is that low salary + less benefits + no bonus could be a net loss for me. I work for a non profit now and while our financial future is bleak, I am paid fairly with fully paid high quality health insurance and good retirement and until recently was eligible for bonus, if this job is straight salary, it would net me less than I make today. I don't want to waste anyone's time but a 20K loss to my salary is not something I will consider.
2
1 Reply
Claudia
278
Current events call for adapting new solutions.
01/11/21 at 11:03PM UTC
in
Oh, yes, ALWAYS ask for the range! I'm surprised that wouldn't be published with a state govt job.
And state jobs frequently pay lower than private sector, or pay at the lower end for the same job - which is why it's so hard sometimes to get skilled and experienced workers at higher levels of state govt that come in from outside locations (for us, especially the non-profit sector, because we'd kill to have them but we pay garbage comparatively). The gamble is the job can be lost at any time in private sector, compared to the consistent reliability of state work existing. Sometimes, it's worth it.
1 Reply
Anonymous
01/12/21 at 6:27PM UTC
in
Thanks. The range is advertised, it's $120-130K. I make $124 now plus an average 3K bonus and I have fully paid healthcare. This role is with a state university and I fear the job stability of many other public jobs would not be there as the role of colleges changes and these administrative roles are likely on the chopping block. Our state has had layoffs of university staff before.
I applied but I think I might have to pass it just doesn't sound like would be a good move for me.
Reply
Ckirt
16
01/12/21 at 2:13PM UTC
in
I just want to add that employers know what they have to offer. If this is a more secure job in COVID climate, they may be less willing to negotiate if they have many candidates. They may want someone who will be satisfied and accept what they are offering. What they need to know is that you are the best choice/fit (without doubt) and worth the negotiation. If they are unwilling, are you still open to accept the position? Know your worth!
Reply
Joyce Wallace
110
Technology, Operations, and Finance Executive
01/11/21 at 6:58PM UTC
in
I have worked in state and local government settings in various states. Here are the things to be aware of:
1. The advertised salary range is just that - the minimum to maximum pay range. In extremely rare cases, I've seen maximums raised for very high level executives (but it requires approval, usually by a Board or CEO).
2. Placement on a step is negotiable but depends highly on the rules of that jurisdiction. It can be as simple as exceeding the years of experience requirement or as cumbersome as pointing out ways you exceed other minimum requirements (e.g., having a BS when no degree is required, certifications, etc.).
3. Other perks such as vacation time are often negotiable. Don't be afraid to ask.
4. READ THIS - Most important of all, once you're in that government entity - future salary increases, vacation accruals, etc. are constrained by your current compensation, even in California where basing an offer on past salary history is illegal in the private sector! There are always rules on increases and they almost never have anything to do with your performance. Therefore, you MUST negotiate everything you can (once you secure a job offer) because you won't have another opportunity. I've actually seen people leave government jobs and come back as a "new" employee because it was more financially beneficial (although many jurisdictions have rules that discourage this).
Good luck!
3
1 Reply
Anonymous
01/11/21 at 7:40PM UTC
in
This would absolutely be a 2-3 year job for me. I am trying to get experience in the academic sector and this would allow me to do that at a community college so that I could move onto a private university where there is much more income potential. I would not plan to spend the next 15 years of my career as a state employee.
User edited comment on 01/11/21 at 8:01PM UTC
Reply
Anonymous
01/13/21 at 1:40PM UTC
in
I work in a city agency and the range is the range because of labor union negotiations (as well as PTO time). No one is able to start above the range and our salaries are strictly calculated using a formula based on experience. On the flipside, I would say that the hours are great and I am eligible for comp time.
User edited comment on 01/13/21 at 1:42PM UTC
Reply
Anonymous
01/13/21 at 1:45PM UTC
in
I will also add, securing these government jobs can be a headache. In my experience (communications/public relations background), they want an extremely qualified candidate whose experience aligns perfectly with the job description within that specific industry (I.e my specific government background hasn’t been able to translate into other areas of state government) . For me personally, the industries my career field exists in is endless, so not being able to have that hop around ability specifically in government has been a headache.
It’s important to note there is also A LOT of inside ball. Often times, they already have someone in mind when the position is posted, so network, network, network.
With all of this being said, I think it’s worth applying! If you have the experience to justify the higher end of the bracket, absolutely fight for it.
The last thing to consider are these few questions:
1. Would you be willing to take the position if it paid the same?
2. If so, will this position provide you with experience that will contribute to the growth of your career?
3. Is this a position you actually want or is it more of a scapegoat?
Good luck in your hunt!
Reply
Anonymous
01/13/21 at 2:58PM UTC
in
I worked in a state job for 10 years, and was told when I was offered my first position that the only option you have to negotiate salary is at the very beginning. After that you are stuck into the pay grid that is established by the contract. If the hiring manager for this position hadn't shared that fact I never would have known.
1
Reply
Looking for a new job?
Our employer partners are actively recruiting women! Update your profile today.
The Fairygodboss Feed
We're a community of women sharing advice and asking questions