Job postings aren't for actual current openings

I've come to the upsetting revelation that some job postings are not for open positions. Reasons I've heard are that the job needs to be publicly posted to show that there was a search, and the position is filled by an internal employee or someone else already in mind; or the company is collecting resumes for later. I think the first reason already existed before covid. And don't get me wrong -- I would be happy to hear that a company was able to retain or call back an employee into a different position -- I just wish it wasn't posted for me to see! The "later" reason doesn't make sense to me either. Why refer to a batch of stale resumes later? Er, that is, if "later" ever comes?

I have lost so much sleep applying to jobs and I feel so defeated and unmotivated knowing that some percentage of these were not even actual openings. Doesn't HR know how time-consuming and mentally draining applying for jobs is!! How can they treat job seekers like this? As if we aren't busy enough!

The only way I've seen to get around this is to ask. I've had luck ONCE of getting my time saved, not applying to a post for a job that actually wasn't open; my rate of responses from people inside companies is low. I'd love for anyone reading this to tell me I'm wrong, that no dear, every job posting is for an actual opening; or a better way to tell if it is.

Desperate and pissed,
Anonymous

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

24 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Jackie Ghedine

    Unfortunately, looking on job boards is a really difficult way to get a job. 70% of jobs that are available never get posted on job boards. Then there's over 70% of jobs that are posted are filled through networking and not through traditionally resume submissions. This leaves your chances of finding a job through a board very slim.

    All is not lost, instead adjust how you search for a job. Use every networking connection you have to let people know of the position you are looking to obtain. Be very succinct and specific on what you want to make it easy for someone to recommend you. Reach out to people within organizations you're interested in to see if you can have a virtual coffee with them, so many people are kind and will take the time to chat.

    If you've exhausted your LinkedIn network, try to find ways to expand your network naturally. Think about getting involved with associations or connect with your alumni group.

    Good luck.

  2. Alexandra Riggs

    This is a great advice but from my personal experience is it is more demotivating to look for a job through networking on LinkedIn. Very few people care and respond unless you know them well.

  3. Jackie Ghedine

    It can be daunting, but no more than sending out resumes to job boards and getting no replies or standard rejection letters.

    The entire process is a test of resilience and confidence and all of this can tear it down if we let it. Just expanding your ability to network can make a world of difference. Good luck.

  4. Anonymous

    Thank you, Jackie!! Your middle paragraph is full of wonderful suggestions that I can act on now. Please keep your fingers crossed for me.

  5. Jackie Ghedine

    Fingers (and toes) crossed for you!

  6. Patricia Osborne Randolph

    Jackie, thanks for the networking suggestion. I am curious if networking for open job positions in corporate companies is a possibility for professional individuals of color? This year has brought the insight of the lack of equality and diversity in corporate America. I have experienced and witnessed attempts by individuals of color at networking for corporate positions with little to no success. Are there any thoughts or guidance you could suggest to colored professional about how to successfully network in a professional corporate environment where the majority of executives or upper management may not be individuals of color?

  7. Jackie Ghedine

    Hi Patricia.
    I can imagine how discouraging it is to network at your organization when there is no one like you in leadership who can help support and understand the biases. I work with a diverse clientele who face the fact that their executive teams don't have many, often times no diversity. What I suggest is to learn the art of confidently bragging. As women especially, we let our work speak for us but that doesn't actually help us gain traction.
    1. Create opportunities to share successful projects you are working on, the goal is to showcase how you are an asset to the company.

    2. Make your presence known instead of leaning back in the background. Sometimes it's easier to just be present than to be seen and learning to get comfortable stepping us is critical. Take small steps to get used to it since it may feel uncomfortable, Patricia. Speak up at meetings and show your value.

    3. Be yourself. Don't morph to meet biases where they are, instead showcase exactly who you are and the power diversity brings to an organization.

    With COVID happening, live networking opportunities are limited so this opens up online networking to even greater capacity. Leverage LinkedIn to make connections, ask questions and share your own expertise by commenting or creating content.

    I hope that helps!

  8. Patricia Osborne Randolph

    Thank you for the suggestions! I have never been one to morph to meet bias. In my experience it has been a slippery slope when an individual of color speaks up and shares ideas in a professional corporate position with limited diversity. If one speaks up and agrees with the majority idea she risks being labeled as "compliant, brown nosing." If one attempts to be assertive and present ideas or suggestions of improvement she risks being labeled as the "angry black female." Hopefully things will improve with the 2020 "woke" protests.

  9. Jackie Ghedine

    The angry black female label is horrific. I do believe organizations are starting t wake-up so continue sharing your voice internally without an eye towards everyone else's perceptions.

    Often times, we feel like we are being judged (sometimes we are) but even if someone thinks something for a moment, those judgements are fleeting (there's scientific proof of this).

    Continue to be your amazing, confident and authentic self. I'm hopeful for the future of diversity in organizations. It's time!

  10. Patricia Osborne Randolph

    Indeed, thank you! :-)

  11. Emily Morgan

    I have been having this same issue. Unfortunately, a recruiter I know told me that somewhere around 80-90% of job postings aren't even real. They're either there to just get people's information or they're of the "we already have an internal person for this job but we have to post the job anyway" variety. I try to stick to ones that don't require you to register just to see the job description (LinkedIn, Indeed, and Glassdoor).

  12. Anonymous

    Omg at these numbers!!

  13. Jackie Ghedine

    On top of that, 70% of jobs aren't even posted on job boards so networking is so important.

  14. Alexandra Riggs

    This is the case for many jobs - and I agree this is rather disrespectful. Try to use more niche job boards - those might have more actual positions (as smaller companies do not want to pay for searching unless they have a posting).

  15. Anonymous

    Good tip, thank you!

  16. Anonymous

    The Mgmt and HR at the global Pharma company I used to work for were bone lazy. They had to externally advertise jobs but couldn't be bothered going through 90+ applications, shortlisting, interviewing etc. They asked employees who they knew...and filled most jobs that way. If external applicants knew this, they'd be devastated they weren't even considered.

  17. Anonymous

    ME^ I guess it goes back to "it's who you know"...

  18. Steph McDonald

    Good companies will post a job as "evergreen" or a "talent community" which allows them to keep in touch for when jobs open again. Resume farming is real, and I hate it. I would suggest when you find a job on a job board, go directly to the companies page and apply via their site vs the job board. First, it's likely still open, second sometimes job boards scrape jobs from employers pages and post it with wrong information. I just found 20 jobs of mine posted as though they were in India, which they aren't. I always assume good intent, but this almost seems like a scam and can reflect on my company vs the job site.

    Please feel free to connect with me on LinkedIn (www.linkedin.com/in/greatrecruiter) and I'll help you as best I can! Stay strong.

  19. Chloe Nguyen

    This came up on my LinkedIn, quite timely: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/expert-tip-find-hidden-job-market-cayla-dengate/

  20. Krista Coutts

    I am right there with you! It is really frustrating and discouraging! But unfortunately, I think that is the time that we are in currently. What is more frustrating to me is seeing great positions, but over 600 candidates vying for that position. How do you break thru?

  21. Krystin Morgan

    I work in recruiting and can say that I've never seen a fake job posting anywhere I've worked. I definitely don't believe the statistics out there about 80%+ of jobs not being real! What does sometimes happen is that a job is posted to collect applicants to get a head start - if you know you'll be hiring in a month, you might post the job to get the word out early. However, I think companies need to make it clear that it's a "hiring soon" thing vs. "hiring right now."

  22. Anonymous

    At my company "turn and burn" positions are always posted. There will be an opening sooner rather than later. That may be another reason to shy away from an evergreen post.

  23. Anonymous

    This has been the case in tech for at least two decades. Lots of positions posted that are not filled. Often they are posted over and over again.

  24. Motta

    It might suck, but that is the nature of the game.
    And if HR wants to have some resumes as backup, what is wrong with that?
    I have gotten some calls from some companies in the past, based on old resumes they had.
    By then I already had a new job, so wasn't interested, but good to know some folks have me in their lists...

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members