Hello!

Hello! I could really use some help!

I received a job offer end of day Thursday due this coming Monday. Knowing that women often do not negotiate and the salary being slightly under my first pay, I prepared a email response with a slightly higher figure for their consideration.

The role is in a non-profit so I purposely chose a smaller number rather than a higher figure they can negotiate down so they wouldn't feel I was snubbing their offer in any way, even if this meant less money it was okay with me. I would ultimately sign the existing offer because I do really want this jobs, I just thought I should at least try to negotiate.

I realize in hindsight I should have had this conversation on the phone, but the response is due Monday and I wanted to give them as much time as possible to decide.

Yesterday, I waited all day for a response and nothing came. Around 3pm I got nervous and made the mistake of calling the operations manager to ask where things were at. I flubbed the call and it was terribly awkward. She was able to tell me she had passed my request onto the ED and should have an answer back to me by Monday. The thing is this organization has always been delayed on emails back to me, so I'm trying to prepare how to respond on Monday so I don't lose the offer.

I feel like my safest option might be to call again if I haven't heard by late Monday afternoon and ask how they would like me to proceed given the deadline. But, I am worried about further irritating the ops manager who has already explained the decision is out of her hands.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!! I really just want to work here and I am starting to regret not just signing the offer on hand and avoiding this stress altogether.

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

9 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Pat Roque

    Congrats! Know that companies are hungry for great employees. Please give yourself more credit and stop feeling as though you’re bugging them.

    You’re not.

    It’s your responsibility to follow up and to negotiate for what you deserve.

    You can ask, “how can I best show my diligence without becoming a pain (with a smile or lol)?”

    Look in the mirror and say some positive affirmations. Google or find an app, there are plenty out there.

    Confidence is your best answer, you’ve got this!

  2. Saudia Santure

    Stop calling!! Give them time to get their heads straight. You already said their email is delayed. You look needy and annoying (sorry if that hurts, truly). I'd wait it out. Let them consider and get back to you.
    Best luck to you!!

  3. Anonymous

    Hi, I feel your predicament.

    You did respond before Monday, and just because you did not accept the offer your response is still a response.

    The "offer stage" is also the "negotiating stage." Once a counter offer is made ( your response) , they must look at their budget to determine how much room or if they have room to wiggle. They have to look at they numbers & decide if it will be sustainable for them in the long run too. Hiring teams expect candidates to negotiate.

    Additionally, negotiating demonstrates that you know your worth.

    Since you called on Friday at 3pm, give them time to get in on Monday and look at your counter. Do not call on Monday!

    I would recommend emailing them on Wednesday, and ask if your counter was being considered while expressing your continued interest ( without sounding desperate) to work there.

    Finally, do not sign the original offer. On negotiators, the your counter is the new offer and the conversation must go from there.

    And, keep looking for other opportunities still. ( This is the hardest thing to do especially when you're so close to an offer).

    Hope this helps you and all the best!

  4. Anonymous

    Thanks for this advice, I know you are right in general, but I feel worried about my security and wellbeing. If it is more important to me to have the job then the negotiated salary should I consider signing the offer? I know this sounds wishy washy but, I've been out of the job market for a significant amount of time and it has taken me a lot of effort and courage to finally get this offer after a lot of second places. It wouldn't be worth it to me to lose the offer over a few thousand dollars even if it makes me look desperate. I'm just also aware they want this position to start the 15th and I'm scared they might yank it and give it to someone else.

  5. Nicole Fortune

    I agree with the other post, please wait. Also, if things are not what you would like but eager to work for the company before signing please outline the review time periods and eligibility requirements for raise considerations. Honestly consider whether these numbers are ones you can live day to day and manage your affairs.

  6. HILDA G

    I am quite sure that especially in our current situation, patience has never failed anyone who has high hopes and dreams. Have faith! It will be answered.

  7. Lori Schmitz

    Good for you for advocating fr yourself! At this point, it’s their move, so you’ll need to be patient ?.

    A note of advice, in the future, always call, sensitive subjects are best discussed in person vs over email.

    All the best!

  8. Mary Busch

    I just listened to an insightful Freakonomics podcast episode #464 entitled "Will Work from Home Work Forever". This episode delves into research on the topic of productivity and the evidence shows WFH increases productivity and job satisfaction. Although it does make the case that innovative ideas don't usually happen over zoom calls. It happens through serendipitous human interactions when you bump into a colleague at the water cooler or cafeteria. It's likely that a hybrid model where you WFH some days of the week and go into office a few others will end up being the dominant model. As for me, my job is 100% remote which I enjoy but I must admit I didn't really make a real connection with my colleagues until I was able to personally meet with them.

  9. Daisy

    You never know unless you ask...and many do not. Do it and stick your chest out, knowing to your worth. Be sure to check Glassdoor to get an idea of range if needed.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members