Negotiating a New Salary for a New Title/Promotion I am in the process of discussing a much needed and desired change to my current role.

Negotiating a New Salary for a New Title/Promotion

I am in the process of discussing a much needed and desired change to my current role. The person I report to has referenced that this would be a ‘bump’ for me, as splitting my role will

create an opportunity for advancement for someone else; nothing has been decided with regard to a new title yet.

I have been promoted twice since being hired - I have invested 15+ years with my organization - I am not sure I want to move on - and I am without question part of their succession plan for the future. (All of which is wonderful and appreciated!)

That being said, I have previously done a poor job of negotiating new salaries at my company and would love some advice. Is it unreasonable to expect that a salary bump for a true promotion, with more scope and responsibility, not be based in part on my current salary? How do I get my employer to consider the knowledge and experience I bring to the table as their SME when discussing the increase? I realize in many cases, changing employers is the way to reap salary gains - but what about the cost of trying to replace me? When does that get taken into consideration? Can I ever expect to be paid fair market value for a role, or will I always be hindered by my current rate of pay?

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

6 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Alyson Garrido, Career Coach

    Great questions!

    You could ask about the salary band for the new role as a starting point - that way your new salary is independent of your current rate. When discussing the raise, share market research that aligns with the role to further make your case along with all of the skills that you bring.

    I hope this is helpful! Wishing you all the best in your negotiation.

  2. Aubrey Armes

    Great question! One of my clients just negotiated a $40,000 pay increase on her job offer.

    @Alyson Garrido has an excellent point about asking them what the salary range is for the position. The burden should be on the company to do their research on what the market compensation is for that particular position, but you need to do your own research as well and pull it out if needed.

    Regarding your question about is it reasonable to expect a pay bump based on the position and not your current wage - yes! Women will never reach pay equity if employers continue to use their current wage to justify their future wage.

    It would be best if you had a goal of what new salary you'd like to reach based on the new role and responsibilities, what the market says for compensation, and what results you know you can create for the business.

    If they don't reach your pay expectations, that's when you negotiate and bring your best business case why it's in their best interest (because it will actually be less expensive) to give you the additional salary amount. This is where you bring in your value of being an SME, part of the long-term business growth strategy, the tribal knowledge that you have, etc. Position it all as trying to create a win-win-win situation for everyone.

    Best of luck to you!

  3. Meghan Leube

    It is absolutely reasonable to request an increase when job duties are changing/increasing. I would suggest making a list of accomplishments and using those as part of the conversation. You have been with the company long term and surely have a lot of institutional knowledge which is invaluable. If you find the salary range is a big jump you could request an incremental increase, some at the point when job duties change and an additional increase in an agreed upon time frame (6 months is probably reasonable). Often managers or leaders want to base new compensation on what a person is currently making but for women and POC that often perpetuates the lower pay rates they have historically been offered. Some companies have limitations/guidelines on the percentage of salary increase that can be offered for promotions which may be a reason to leverage the negotiation of an incremental increase. Good luck!

  4. Kat Dalager

    Also consider alternative forms of compensation, such as stock options, Short Term or Long Term Incentive programs (STI, LTI) or other bonus programs. Those can greatly add to your income and show that you're willing to invest in the company. It also helps you become more savvy about the business.

  5. OklaBella

    To be honest, I bet someone from your HR team would welcome the opportunity to work with you as a partner to help you learn more about the job families within the company, the associated pay ranges, and how they administer their pay. I love for employees to be well informed and honestly support them assertively seeking fair pay within our company. I would just go to them and say "After 15 years of really enjoying my work here I'd like to better understand what our pay administration looks like." or something along those lines.

    If they are not as welcoming, you could simply request the pay ranges for your current job family and the new job family (if applicable) - assure them that you will treat the information as confidential and will not share it outside of the organization. That should show you the established pay ranges for each level. Also, ask if they have leveling guidelines that show the different requirements and responsibilities for each position. The leveling guidelines will tell you what additional experience/level of responsibility they see as applicable to the new role. Then you can do your homework on calculating your compa ratio (what you are paid vs. what their range says the market pays for the position) and the factors (such a niche skills, SME capacity) that will justify you being paid above market value in the new role.

    If they say they don't have established ranges or leveling guidelines I would respond "I appreciate you being transparent about that.
    Would you mind walking me through the internal process and associated data points used to determine internal pay changes?"

    Don't be shy about asking. I assure you, after 15+ years you are a valued member of the team and there is nothing wrong with asking for what information might be available to help you decide if it makes sense financially for you to continue your contribution there.

  6. Anonymous

    Thank you! We’re a smallish, privately held company, with a slew of unique roles - all of which seem to fall to different definitions of responsibility in the ‘hierarchy’. If there are no established levels or guidelines, how do I work from there? I’m not necessarily trying to justify more than market value - but I’m definitely underpaid now, and I really want to break the cycle, especially as I advance.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members