I've made it through the final interview round for my dream job and it's down to 2 candidates, me and another guy.

I've made it through the final interview round for my dream job and it's down to 2 candidates, me and another guy.

I've worked in a volunteer capacity with this organization in the past, and my maybe-future-boss reached out to me to consider applying (they may have also reached out to the other person too, idk).

My interview process went fast, with quick requests for the next rounds and my 2nd and 3rd interviews a day apart. They were often scheduled at 9am, as soon as their work day started, which says to me that I've been at the top of consideration (or maybe that's just when I fit into the schedule). The hiring director complimented me on my thourough work and how they've seen me grow through the interview process.

At first I was told I'd hear something earlier this week. Then I was told yesterday. Now I've been told that it will be early next week because the CEO needs to have a final review. I understand this because I know it's important for the CEO to know and approve who they're bringing onto their team, and I'm sure the CEO has been busy.

However, the waiting is making me extremely nervous because with the pace of my interviews, I thought I might have gotten an offer a week ago (and I assumed they were interviewing other candidates, but now it's confirmed). I go back and forth between "You've got this!" and "Prepare for 'we've gone a different route.'" Clearly, I wouldn't have made it 3 rounds without being a solid candidate, and I know I'm talented at what I do (although I'm an introvert, I'm also a "people person" - and this is an outreach role).

What is the CEO's typical role in final candidate selection? Do they review and approve the final selected candidate? Or do they serve as a tie breaker/final decision maker between the final candidates?

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

4 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Käte Davis

    It just depends on the organization and the job level. If this one is close to the CEO, he/she may want to have more of a say. So I'd take it as a compliment that the big boss wants to vet you!

  2. Anonymous

    This truly depends on the business and organization. Some they just need a signature and others are very involved in the decision making process. They may serve as a tie breaker but again it depends on the organizational structure.

    The waiting is the worst part especially when you want the job so badly. Here's hoping you hear soon!

  3. Anonymous

    It all depends on the conversations the CEO is having internally. If they are not hearing a decisive & collective argument for one candidate over the other, then the CEO will weigh in. If there is a clear best fit, then the CEO generally reviews the notes and recommendations and blesses the choice. Seldom does a CEO override his team's decision.

  4. Marissa

    I think it really depends on the size and type of company you are applying at. Unless they told you the CEO is making a decision with final candidates, you are making an assumption there are others. The question could be deciding whether they think you will be a good fit with the company, maybe they have the final say in your benefits/pay, or your interviewers just need a stamp of approval. Who knows!?

    Try and get out of your head about it! They asked you to apply, you interviewed well, and you've made it to the final round. You have the experience with the org. as a volunteer which is also a plus. If they don't hire you, they would be foolish.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members