I am not a HR professional, I am an product executive in startup land and I feel like I'm always looking for my "next gig", so I'll share a sorta-related opposite story.
I was contacted by a recruiter for a large firm for a similar role that I currently held. I was not actively looking for work but as I said above, I'm always looking for the next gig either actively or passively.
I reviewed the job and researched the company. I was very clear when I interview that not every position is meant for me and that I would only move from my current position is if it was the right fit -- position, culture, team etc. I am very frank that I'm interviewing the company as much as they are interviewing me.
I went through 4 or 5 interviews over the course of 4 to 6 weeks. I was then told the position was between me and someone else, and after a week or so, I received a call from the initial recruiter saying that the company choose the other person.
She had no feedback on why they selected the other person above me, they just selected the other person (sometimes someone else clicks with a team) and that I shouldn't be upset that I didn't get the job, which I thought was an odd thing to say, because I was not upset.
I reminded her (nicely) that she reached out to me about the position and I had enjoyed learning about the company, going through the interview process, and meeting the people on the team, but I was not upset that I didn't get the job and I understand that sometimes the other person is a better match"
She was really taken aback that I would say such a thing - "the company reached out to me as a passive job-seeker and I'm not upset that I didn't get the job." and then she got upset with me for saying that they reached out to me. "Didn't I know that it's normal course of recruiting for them to reach out to me? "
I realized quickly that I had "stepped in something" with her and I deescalated the direction this conversation was heading.
I have had many interviews in my career (active, passive, formal and informal) and this was one of the oddest "you didn't get the job" conversations I have ever had.
Share your insight
Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.
3 Comments
Join the conversation