Paper Company

I’ve applied to this stationery company a million times for some things I admit I’m not qualified for and for others I definitely qualify for. I’ve been shut down by HR for no reason and I’ve even tried to ask them on what basis I’m being rejected. I’ve also tried to tap into LinkedIn and speak to company members about the company the hiring process and I’ve either gotten no response or an “you can speak to our hiring manager”
I’ve tried everything, I’ve even personally dropped off my resume and portfolio to them and no response as well. Most people would give up right now but I really want to work there and can’t seem to even get my foot in the door.

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

19 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. MichelleS

    Have you tried connecting with people at the company? Maybe you have a 2nd or 3rd connection...or maybe you can just reach out to see if they are open to networking. Once you establish a relationship they can possibly help you get in.

  2. Anonymous

    This^^^ In the current company that I do now work for, this happened to me. I couldn't understand why I couldn't obtain a position that I knew I was qualified for. I had old coworkers that worked there that I reached out to and found out that they did a lot of internal hiring for the positions that I had posted for. I told him what position I really was looking at and he went to the hiring director and asked him to give me a chance. I had a couple of interviews and was hired.

  3. Anonymous

    Thank you for your input, yes I’ve tried to speak to someone at the company however I don’t really know anyone there, and when ived reached out it hasn’t been helpful.

  4. Ms. Ballesteros

    Thank you for your response! Yes I have it seems they give me the cold shoulder, it doesn’t seem to get anywhere. They either ignore me or just say things along the lines of “ please speak to my hiring manager”

  5. Mary Meffe

    Sometimes we have to accept reality. Even if you managed to get them to hire you, it would mean working with people who have made it clear that they are not interested in working with you. Go to a local employment agency and find a job that is right for you and for the company.

  6. Anonymous

    Thank you for response, yes that’s very true. I just want to contribute to this company but it does seem that they only hire a certain set of people

  7. Lady Pele

    I'm sorry to say this, but if you've applied for jobs for which you knew you weren't qualified, that doesn't help you. It can cause HR and/or the hiring manager to question your ability to comprehend requirements and your decision-making ability. If you've done it multiple times, you could have earned a black mark in their system.

    All I can think of is look at LinkedIn for people in the position you want at that company and attempt to connect. Be sure to add a comment to the connection request like "I am also a (insert role) and would like to connect". Try to establish a relationship before asking for things. For example, talk about the priorities in your job and ask if they're the same for the connection. Talk about the hardest thing you've dealt with (and how) and ask about their experiences. Once you've established that relationship, you can say that you are interested in the company and does he/she think you would be a good fit for their culture.

  8. Ruth A. Ford, PHR

    Totally agree with LadyPele. Do not apply for jobs you aren't qualified for. It really doesn't help your cause.

  9. Anonymous

    Yes I understand that, I meant it in terms of just trying to get my foot in the door. Like I qualify for it but maybe in their eyes I may not. Like I know the software for example and could perform all the duties but haven’t performed that specific job. So i May feel like I’m qualified but in their eyes they may look at the jobs I’ve worked and say hmm it doesn’t exactly match.

  10. Shernette Linton, JD | Certified Professional Resume Writer & Career Coach - CPRW, CPCC

    It sounds like you are trying to make a career transition from one kind of position/industry to another. That can be frustrating, and it takes work.
    - Your resume must convince the hiring manager that the skills you used in past positions are readily transferable to the position you are seeking.
    - Your resume must demonstrate that you meet 85 - 90% of the requirements of your target position, or you probably won't be considered a strong candidate.
    - When you look objectively at the requirements for the positions to which you have been applying, do you meet at least 85-90%?
    - If you meet that threshold, your challenge is to draft (or have someone draft) a resume that clearly demonstrates this.

    You will need good networking skills.
    - However, if your resume isn’t on point when you reach out to your network, your connections will be reluctant to pass your resume along.

    You’ve said that you’ve been shut down by HR for no reason. There is a reason HR isn't responding.
    - As LadyPele commented, it could be that you’ve been black-marked for applying to multiple positions for which you don't seem qualified (it can make you seem desperate and unfocused, and no one wants to hire a desperate, unfocused job seeker).
    - It could be that you really don't meet enough of the requirements.
    - It could be that your resume is not doing a good job of positioning you.

    Before you send another application, I would suggest that you get clear on how you stack up against the requirements of your top target position. If you meet the 85-90% threshhold, get some help to draft a resume that positions you for a transition to that role. Then focus on getting an interview for that position only (or closely similar ones). If you don’t meet the requirements, begin to work on ways to get the necessary skills to strengthen your candidacy for the future.

    Also brush up on your networking skills. If your first outreach is an ask, people will shy away.

    Best of luck!

  11. Anonymous

    Thank you for your response! Yes, I agree and can see how applying to multiple jobs can hurt my chances. I mean that I’ve applied to positions every few months or so, and for positions I know I qualify for, it just seems that experience may be in the eye of the beholder. What I mean is I feel that they are only looking at resumes with 20 years experience with the same job title that they are applying for.

    For example, here are the requirements for a position I have applied for titled “store front position”

    Excitement about working for a brand that creates well-made, inspiring products that make everyday life more beautiful

    Bright, cheerful demeanor

    Ability to communicate effectively in order to relay product knowledge and services

    Strong verbal and written skills

    Ability to perform effective selling techniques to achieve the sale and repeat business

    Basic computer skills

    Ability to work a flexible schedule including holidays, overnights, weekends

    Prior retail experience a plus

    Ability to lift /carry/move 40 lbs minimum including fixtures and product

    Intuitive and teachable in product assembly and production

    Ability to work with your hands assembling small components

    Ability to stand for long periods of time

    Ability to climb ladders and work on elevated surfaces from time to time

    Basic merchandising skills and an eye for detail

    Ability to resolve customer service issues and concerns, utilizing resources available

    Someone who takes initiative

    And I’ve asked the person in HR what requirements I am missing . To which she answered l ppl“ we are looking for people with retail experience“ and I explained that I worked retail in highschool but didn’t think it was relevant to put something that old on a resume, especially when this seems like an entry level position. Anyways I asked her if I could redo my resume and resubmit it with the appropriate experience, and she said she would pass it along. Then the next day I get an email rejecting me.

    Thank you again for your input, yes you are right my degree is in math so I’ve been working as teacher and want to break into this boutique stationery company as a designer.

  12. Shernette Linton, JD | Certified Professional Resume Writer & Career Coach - CPRW, CPCC

    HR told you why you aren’t being considered--you haven't demonstrated that you have the required experience. I suspect your resume is saying "teacher, teacher," while you're applying for a "store front” position. They're probably getting tons of resumes from applicants with store front experience--they're not going to give a teacher resume a second glance. If you think about it from the employer's viewpoint, why would they? How would HR justify sending your resume on to the hiring manager?

    Also, if your resume is going through screening software (called the applicant tracking system - ATS) that scans for keywords that match the job requirements, it’s probably getting rejected before a human even lays eyes on it.

    The transition you are trying to make isn’t impossible, but it probably won’t come by continuing to throw resumes at them. If what you’re doing isn’t working, doing more of it isn’t going to change the results.

    Based on all you've said, it sounds as though you need help with repositioning your resume, networking techniques, and how to conduct a career transition job search. You’ll also need a strong (not long) cover letter that supports your re-positioning.

    Does your college offer job search help to its alumni, or does your local library offer resume writing and job search help? If you would like to have a free one-on-one consult with me (I’m itching to see your resume! :-) ), feel free to contact me at shernette@march4thcareerservices.com.

    Best of luck!

  13. Anonymous

    Yes, that makes sense and I understand, my resume does have that because its all I've done, and do not want to put a blank resume. I was hoping that HR would read more into the resumes they receive and I dont mean to be snooty or put others down, but i have looked on Linkedin at the experience of others, some of which have only been interns, or current undergraduate students in art or marketing. I also do not mean to detract from others but I can definitely see that they only hire people with a certain look or background because everytime I have visited the storefront, there is not a good range of representation.

    It is entirely possible that the way my resume is formatted could be hurting my chances. I am working on having a separate one with just a simple formatting that can easily been tailored to a specific position and reading by those scanners.

    Yes, I have been turned down enough to somewhat get the hint that I need to change course or direction. Or to just somewhat stick to what I have a background in.

    Sure, haha its probably not that impressive once I email it. Thank you for all your help, yes I email it to you and brief background summary so that my whole history makes sense. Thank you for connecting and I hope to hear from you soon.

  14. Amanda Neighbours

    Can I ask why you really want to work there? They don't seem to be treating candidates well.

  15. Anonymous

    I honestly don’t know why other than I just really want to contribute to the team. Like I feel that I can make new designs for their stationery but I’ve been in a certain role since college. So like I’ve said in other comments, I know the software, know how to perform the duties but only have had a certain job title so it seems that they Just write me off and there’s no one to speak to or really get my foot in the door.

  16. Anonymous

    I agree with the question of why you are so intent on working for this particular company?

    I suggest that you widen your search to include similar firms... which would welcome you.

  17. Anonymous

    Thank you for response! I don’t know how to explain it other than I know I can make similar designs that they do. Like I feel that I have a style that works well with the products they put out but they don’t seem to care.

  18. Sandra Diaz

    Here's a crazy idea: what if you sign up for SendOutCards.com and mail the hiring manager (head of Design) one card a week with your designs for 4 weeks. Find out details about this company and their customers, wins and challenges. Write a compliment or suggestion on your card with a P.S. saying this card was designed by you and you'd like the opportunity to chat with him/her on how you could add value to their team.

  19. Anonymous

    Thank you! Yes I could do that and might do so, I just feel that since I’ve already dropped off my portfolio, and they haven’t responded to that, it may come off as too much. I honestly don’t know what to do though so thank you for the helpful suggestion.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members