Applying for Positions

Due to Covid-19, I am back on the job market after only 4.5 years of steady work. Something new this time is that every single job I apply for asks me for some optional demographic information - my Sex, Race, Veteran Status and Disabilities as well as if I am legally able to work in the US. Are decisions being made off this data? Should I opt-out of answering these questions? Thank you!

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

11 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Kacy

    My experience as a hiring manager is that these questions are super standard and are sometimes just part of the HR process. I've never had it actually impact who I hire.

  2. Anonymous

    I was also upset about those questions - why does it matter if I am a male or female? Is there a reason for collection? Also, as a hiring manager do you think cover letter makes a big difference? Do managers have time to read those?

  3. Kacy

    Others below provided better answers to your first question than I would have, so I'll skip to your next one.

    Yes, a cover letter can make a huge difference - in a good way and a bad way. The worst thing you can do is submit a bland and generic cover letter that adds nothing to your application; that is a waste of time and turns me off from a candidate. I may not even spend much time on your resume.

    However, if you put some thought into it and make it worth my time to read it, you will then stand out from the rest of the candidates. It doesn't take much effort on your part to customize it for each application, so if you are going to submit one, do it right. Include something in there that can't be found on your resume. Do not just summarize your resume. Do some research on the company, the hiring manager if you know who it is, or even the industry and make a connection between that and 1) why you are a good fit, and/or 2) why you want to work there, or 3) what they will gain by hiring you. Everyone is looking for a new job, everyone wants to grow their career, give me something more in your cover letter!

    Hiring is exhausting, so give the hiring manager something to remember you by in your cover letter. They will appreciate a break from the monotony of terrible cover letters and resumes.

  4. Anonymous

    I was also upset about those questions - why does it matter if I am a male or female? Is there a reason for collection? Also, as a hiring manager do you think cover letter makes a big difference? Do managers have time to read those?

  5. Jennifer Thornton

    It's common to ask if you are legal to work in the US. Since citizen ship or a visa is required. I'm surprised by the sex, race, disability questions. These are all protected by EEOC guidelines. As an HR consultant, I would never recommend a company put these questions on an application.

  6. Melissa Boillot, SHRM - SCP

    I can't speak for all companies of course, but my organization only uses this for EEO reporting to the government, and never to include/exclude candidates from the hiring process.

  7. Anonymous

    Having this data helps a company assess for bias in the hiring process, but is NOT to be used for decision making, with the exception of the US work status piece. Companies should be very clear in their applications how that information is used and how it isn't, though.

  8. Debra Sesholtz

    As Melissa mentioned, usually it will state the company is required to collect this info for government reporting purposes. You also usually have the option to select I’d rather not answer. If you are disturbed by the question, then you should select that response.

  9. Amy Fortney

    ^^^ This. You may be offended that they ask, but it's required by federal law that employers ask if they want to self-identify for purposes of making sure that they don't discriminate against those people when hiring. Hiring managers are not given this information. This is the language that the EEOC suggests accompany those voluntary questions: "The employer is subject to certain governmental recordkeeping and reporting requirements for the administration of civil rights laws and regulations. In order to comply with these laws, the employer invites employees to voluntarily self-identify their race or ethnicity. Submission of this information is voluntary and refusal to provide it will not subject you to any adverse treatment. The information obtained will be kept confidential and may only be used in accordance with the provisions of applicable laws, executive orders, and regulations, including those that require the information to be summarized and reported to the federal government for civil rights enforcement. When reported, data will not identify any specific individual. " From a disabilities perspective, it's the same. The ADA requires employers to make sure that they are not discriminating against hires and that they consider them with or without reasonable accomodation to do the job.

  10. Kimberly Basford

    Those questions, in my experience, are only there for EEOC reporting and are not (and should not be) used in making hiring decisions. You should be able to opt out of answering them if you are not comfortable answering them.

    To answer another question I saw in the comments: as a hiring manager, I don't bother to read cover letters as I usually don't have time. Just make sure your resume is up to date and highlights all of your relevant experience and you should be fine.

  11. Jacquelyn Lloyd

    The questions are there to collect data to support federal reporting requirements. Progressive employers use this data to track and bolster diversity initiatives. In my experience, the hiring manager DOES GET this information as part of the candidates application packet. It shouldn't be used in interviewing or hiring decisions, but....

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members