Seeking Advice on Navigating Difficult Team Dynamics

Seeking Advice on Navigating Difficult Team Dynamics

Hello, I’m dealing with a challenging situation at work that involves unclear ownership, conflicting expectations, and tension from leadership, and I’m hoping for advice on how to handle it professionally while protecting my well-being.

Here’s the context:

• I’m a valued member of my team with significant responsibilities, but recently I’ve been asked to take on more leadership in a high-priority initiative that’s beyond my current capacity and paygrade, which has created overwhelming pressure.

• There was an agreement to explore alternative approaches for ownership, yet middle management is pushing me to continue leading in a role that I’ve communicated concerns about. A main concern is that a middle manager who is not my leader is influencing and strong-arming my middle manager into agreeing to me doing this. My middle manager has also not made an effort to understand what our team does, and is therefore unaware of how this would create negative implications on current work.

• Despite discussing limits on my role, I recently received last-minute instructions from the other middle manager to proceed with a project plan that completely overlooks the previous discussions. My middle manager seems to be playing both sides of the field.

• There’s internal tension, with some colleagues appearing to side with leadership, which makes me feel unsupported. Other colleagues, while they empathize with me and agree that it is an unreasonable ask, also don’t want to do the job, as there is a lot at stake to do a good job.

• Given the history of drastic actions in my workplace, I’m also concerned about potential retaliation if I don’t comply.

Has anyone dealt with a similar dynamic or had to navigate a situation where workload expectations conflict with your role and the team’s needs? Any advice on how to set boundaries while staying professional in a high-pressure environment?

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

3 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Anonymous

    I'm thinking that you are cornered and nust take on this project so what you will need to do to carve sufficient time and mental space is design a transition plan to hand off your other work to make room for this project. Do this immediately and do it quantitatively ( break this down in hours) and with an aggressive timeline of hand off so you can set yourself up for success. Present it as a "if I am to properly take XYZ on I must transition ABC off to this group by this date. Then set your milestones and deliverables with dates. This way you have set boundaries and expectations. Make it an either or proposition. You either take this off mey plate or I cannot takes on.

  2. Anonymous

    Yes, set boundaries. Sit down with your direct manager and let them know about the conflict. Ask them to broker in between and to set priorities with a worksheet and timelines for deliverables that everyone can commit to. Make a once per week meeting with all the stakeholders and get together during that short 15-30 minute meeting to review and shift only in that meeting. Problem solved. Don't do anything outside of what the commits are going forward.

  3. Christina Weber

    That’s a tough situation that I can empathize with.

    Here are some things to consider:

    1. Clarify and Reaffirm Boundaries

    It sounds like you’ve already communicated your concerns, it may be helpful to document and restate your capacity and the risks involved with taking on additional leadership. Frame it as a shared interest in maintaining the quality of existing work while supporting new initiatives.

    2. Engage in Solutions-Oriented Dialogue

    When addressing leadership, try to frame your concerns alongside possible solutions. Consider, proposing alternatives like distributing tasks across the team or identifying additional resources. This keeps the conversation forward-focused while reinforcing your professional stance.

    3. Document Key Conversations

    Keep a written record of key discussions, agreements, and changes to your responsibilities. This helps ensure clarity and provides a reference if further misalignment occurs.

    4. Protect Your Well-Being

    It's easy to internalize the stress in situations like this. Incorporate small practices to help you stay grounded. Whether it’s creating space for breaks, seeking external mentorship, or focusing on areas within your control, your well-being is essential to sustaining your professional impact!

    Best of luck!

    Warmly, Christina

Browse recent posts

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members