Polling for opinions.

Polling for opinions. I have permanent job that is ok - underpaid, overworked and not an agency that I want to work at forever. I just received an offer for a contractor role that is at a dream company (where I would want to work forever) and aligned with my future goals. It pays more. Contract is up in December - but high likelihood to renew the contract or be able to be fully employed with the larger corporate company. Please share or advise on which path you would take.

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

20 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Anonymous

    Take a chance

  2. Anonymous

    Most contract jobs do not offer medical benefits, so you may have to pay your own benefits. You can make a list and weigh the pros and cons of each employer.

  3. Joan Williams, Senior Talent Acquisition Specialist

    I think what makes people reluctant to do contract is perceived risk. But there is no job security anymore.

    You could get hired to a permanent full time role and get laid off in three months.

    Good contracting companies provide medical benefits, sick time, etc. Sometimes what benefits are available depends on what state you're in if you're in the US.

  4. Barbara M.

    I’m currently in a similar situation. I stepped into a contractor role with a company that aligns strongly with my long-term goals, but with the understanding that conversion to a permanent role is performance-based and not guaranteed.

    What helped me make peace with the uncertainty was looking at the bigger picture. If a role gives you exposure to the kind of work, systems, and people you ultimately want to grow with, it can be a strategic step forward even if it starts as a contract. In many cases, contract roles at strong organizations become extended(as in my case) or converted when you consistently demonstrate value and fit. For me, the deciding factors are growth, alignment with my future direction, and the opportunity to position myself where I ultimately want to be. Stability matters, of course, but so does momentum. Sometimes the “bridge” role opens doors the comfortable role never will.

  5. Hella Willis

    Life is short. You’ll land on your feet.

  6. Tricia

    Stick with your current role unless you can afford the contract not extending and no chance of being hired permanently.. I like the diversity of contract positions but every year you will be stressing to know if you will have another job after the contract ends then unemployed looking as for a job for months.

  7. Anonymous

    What will your future-self regret doing or not doing?

    Anything worth having requires risk.

    Obviously, it’s an easier decision to make the leap once you’ve taken stock of your finances to determine how much runway (i.e. “F-U $$$”) you have before the net appears.
    Worse-case scenario is that you might need to look for another position if the contract role doesn’t become permanent. You’ll still be better off because you’ll have gained new skills and experiences that will keep you moving in the direction you want to go - towards your aligned future goals.

    Contractor @ Dream company + Future Goal Alignment VS.
    Permanent Overworked + Underpaid @ Meh Agency

    “Everything you want is on the other side of fear.”

  8. Anonymous

    I just quit my stable underpaid agency role for a short contract at my dream company that I hope will extend. I just started a week ago and I’m already glad I took the contract because of how much it has changed my perspective. It’s too early for me to know how this plays out but I was just in your shoes and I understand the stress of making this decision (esp in this awful job market.) I will say that I have some degree of stress trying to learn quickly and “prove my keep” in this new position, but I feel so much less stagnant. I’m young (minimal savings but some emergency fund) and I have no kids so I decided to weather some risk. I’d look at how much stress you can handle right and and if you’re ready for a lot of potential unknowns. Wishing you luck!!!

  9. Anonymous

    Only you can make that decision and live with the consequences of leaving something permanent for something risky. Good luck in your decision, but make it knowing that you should continue to look for a full time role while taking that other position, even if its not there.

  10. Liz Milne

    Take the dream job, but immediately establish a second line of income just in case things fall through in December?

  11. Megan Leasher

    The dream job sounds so wonderful, but ultimately, only you can determine how much risk you can introduce in your life. Trust your gut.

  12. Anonymous

    I would take it.

  13. Anonymous

    Depends on how old you are. If you’re over 50 I wouldn’t chance it. Maybe you can work on the contract job after hours? See if they’ll entertain that.

  14. Anonymous

    Trying to think through this advice- it rubs me the wrong way. I think giving up on taking risks after 50 is sad. If there’s a strong reason like vesting or you have a health concern and lack of benefits will hugely impact you, I could understand but OP didn’t mention any of that. Underpaid and overworked sounds like a situation to extract oneself from

  15. Evelyn Livant

    I’m over 50 and can take risks. I think it depends on your specific situation. Are you financially stable?

  16. Anonymous

    Contractor here!

    I accepted a dream contract role with a large multinational company in early 2022. They said they would bring me on as an employee at the earliest opportunity. My team loves me, but the company won’t approve the creation of a new FTE position. Four years in, I’m still a contractor (but it was renewed each year!).

    I knew this could happen, and I am okay with it because I’m getting great experience. Downsides are the benefits truly stink (no PTO or mat leave, $$$ instance). If you can handle the downsides, take the opportunity and get the experience!!

  17. Evelyn Livant

    All of life is a gamble… after 6 years and 5 jobs (reduction of workforce) I don’t consider any job 100% stable.

    It depends on the risk you’re comfortable taking.

    You know your field and your skills and your ability to land work. If you’re confident then take it!

    It’s a bit too late, but I’d try to have a good cushion in savings so you can take this and in case you go between contracts for awhile.

  18. Anonymous

    if they are both work from home; consider working them both for a couple of months if possible . Loyalty to one organization is not advisable

  19. Anonymous

    Go in the direction that aligns with your goals.

  20. Mayra L. Jimenez

    I would shoot my shot and network like heck while i'm there so that when the contract ends, I'll have allies to secure something permanent. I would love an opportunity like this. Go for it!

Browse recent posts

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members