Upset Employee--

Upset Employee--

I recently had to talk to an employee about their hours, they were clocking in at 5:50am when the store doesn't open until 7:00am. It only takes 30 minutes to open, so I informed them that they would need to start work and clock in at 6:30am instead. They took the news personal, and said they are being picked on. They are very upset with me and even stated that they would be more closed off now and refuse to open up to me in the future (this was a very personal hit because I thought we considered each other friends). They were allowed to come in so early for so many years, but the hours of operation do not start until 7. I understand that some people do not like change, but I wish the employee could see it from the business standpoint. I feel awful that I upset them and wish they wouldn't make me feel so guilty about it, but it was a conversation that needed to take place.

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

11 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Anonymous

    First, do not mix friendships and working relationships, especially if she reports to you.

    Is there a policy you can point to? Is everyone else being treated the same? Have you asked her why she is clocking in that early?

  2. Anonymous

    Everyone else is being treated the same. The employee knows that overtime is monitored, especially when that branch struggles making a profit. I fear that my more "corporate" approach just isn't welcomed to the company - but I am prepared for employees to have backlash. I try to put my job before making or keeping friendships here, but that is something that others do not like and are not used to.

  3. Anonymous

    As a responsible leader you must make the difficult decisions sometimes. I'm not sure what you can do to rectify the mood of the employee. I would be proactive and train a backup in case the person decides they won't show up to open any longer.

  4. Anonymous

    If this is about them losing an hour of pay explain that to them specifically. As for the friendship, well you are acquaintances at work and business is business. Be firm and if they don't like what you have to say and you are their manager sit them down for a reality check. I think what you did is right. They are being unreasonable and just don't get it. Laws would make the company pay for them if they clock in so know that it factors into the equation if they get paid by the hour.

  5. Anonymous

    I'm afraid that they were catered to a little too much. Previous management let them come in and leave when they wanted to, so shame on them. I'm just disappointed by their response and reaction to me, but will continue to remain professional with them and try to lift their spirits eventually.

  6. Anonymous

    Does this employee need special accommodations? Is this the only time they can come in due to transportation? Were they given the earlier time so they can leave earlier? I feel there is more to this than what is told. I would find out more details as to why they were given this time to clock in and allowed to for so long. Change is hard and people hate change, but it has to be done. I hope it works out for each of you.

  7. Anonymous

    Thank you.

    No special accommodations or transportation issues. Previous management just allowed it because that is what the employee wanted, part of it being that the employee's father is a farmer and used to buy a lot of product/services from the company (small town politics at its finest). If this employee were to leave, the replacement would not have the option to choose their schedule and would be told the same thing.

  8. Anonymous

    Upon reading this, I wonder: was the employee being overpaid or not covering required business hours because they clocked in at 5:50 AM? If yes, explaining the business reason sympathetically to the employee should suffice/should have sufficed.

    On the other hand, the employee has been allowed to clock in at 5:50 for many years, which makes me wonder if there is a compelling reason to change this person’s schedule? If not, it might have been reasonable to keep the prior arrangement, especially if the employee is otherwise capable and loyal.

  9. Sanjeet Singh

    thank you for joining

  10. Rebecca Milliken

    Most places I've worked where I punched the clock had specific rules about not punching in more than 5 minutes or 10 minutes early because then at the end of the pay period you end up with overtime or if it's a no overtime allowed situation that person has to go home early and you don't have coverage.

    You should't feel guilty to telling this person something that's common sense, and they shouldn't take it personally.

  11. Maegan, Nike Sales Rep & Career Coach

    Dont take it personally. Ask if they need additional help or processes to open up more efficiently. Is the "closing crew" leaving things unfinished so theres more work to be done in the mornings before the store opens? I think if you show him you are wanting to make things easier for him, even with the new 6:30 clock in, he will feel valued and appreciated.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members