After 3 years, I am now unqualified to do my job.

After 3 years, I am now unqualified to do my job.

Back in 2019, I(38F) started a Call Center Clerk job with School Transportation. The position did not require a CDL as most positions in the department did and it seemed like a standard office do-it-all that I enjoyed. Data entry, Spreadsheets, and Memos, that my jam. It is a salary-paid job which means I do not get paid overtime in money form,, it goes to a time bank of sorts.

Well, that quickly changed due to lack of staff, I became the unofficial Lead Dispatcher which I was very uncomfortable with. Imagine Jess from New Girl navigating bus drivers around town, having teachers and coaches call about late buses, it was not what I was hired to do but over time I have become a pillar if I do say so myself. It is a hard job with very little appreciation. Yes, teachers and schools need more support, but the janitors, lunch staff, bus drivers, and other operations essential to a safe and successful school day are often ignored. I want to add that I take medication for BPD and have adjusted my meds several times to be able to work successfully in a position I learned to love. The nature of the job requires me to work 12–13-hour days sometimes which again, I do not get paid for, it goes into a time bank.

The department got a new director last year (Mr.S) and since then, the department has gotten worst. Veteran drivers and staff that have been there, as long as I have been alive, are commenting on how it’s never been this bad.

Over the summer, my pay and position title did not change, as I was led to believe it would AND I was required to take all my banked time off when they wanted. I decided that I would not work anything over an 8-hour day and that after the school year settled down, I would have to talk to him about my pay.

The first week of school and all staff is to come in at 6:30 am. My scheduled shift is 10 am to 7 pm so I tell him NO and explain to him that 1. I don’t get paid overtime 2. I was forced to take my bank time when the district wanted. 3. No one else is required to work from 6 am to 7 pm. He replied that if I need to take a 3-hour lunch then I could but was still expected to be there at 6 am. I was there and took my 3-hour lunches but this is not a good way to start the school year.

Friday, Mr.S., my direct supervisor, and I have a meeting and I am told that unless I get a CDL, he cannot pay me the Dispatcher pay which is hourly, and would be able to get overtime.

So, the job that I was forced into, was not the one I was hired for, but still, after 3 years of learning and growth and building relationships. A position that I like now that I do damn well, that drivers have told me You’re the best Dispatcher we’ve ever had, and it's because I speak to them with kindness, I have ice pops at the end of a hot day. I am Jess for New Girl in a place where a bit of kindness and glitter was needed but The Call Center Clerk position no longer exists. under the new Dispatcher requirements, I must get a CDL.

I feel heartbroken. The closest feeling, I can compare to it is being dumped. All the talk about, loyalty and appreciation, and leadership applied to everyone but me. I came in early, I stayed late, I covered shifts, if I could do it, I did it but I can’t drive a bus so now I mean nothing. I can’t argue because all office staff is now expected to and most office staff do but even if I wanted my CDL, I would not pass the physical or mental test it requires.

I told him that I was taking the rest of the day off. I don’t think it would sit well with the staff to see me crying and being human, I was upset. I don’t know anyone who could listen to their boss tells you you are not getting paid what you are worth. You are now not worthy of this department without a CDL.

I have applied for a secretary position at another location. It is now clear that I have no future in Transportation

Advice? Comments? Suggestions? Words of Encouragement?

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

4 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Cyndi Rosenblatt

    Is there someone above him you can talk to about the situation? Going outside the chain of command is not usually a great idea, but at this point you have nothing to lose. And if that doesn't work, you also have nothing to lose by telling everyone who is supportive of the job you've been doing that you are being forced to look for other employment because of an unreasonable expectation. The reason they want everyone to have a CDL is so they can sub and you already have too many responsibilities to add that on top. Also maybe consider filing an ADA accommodation. It sounds like health/medical issues make the CDL unattainable, but that shouldn't be a core requirement for the role you've been successfully filling until now.

  2. Anonymous

    Hi Michelle. I am so sorry you are going through this. My guess is that this is a compliance issue, not a personal one. If they are audited, they could be penalized or forced to lay you off if they are found to be non-compliant. If they are forced to lay you off (in a state that requires employers to state a reason), you would have grounds to sue them since non-compliance is their problem and you were "forced" to take on a role for which you were not originally qualified. So a perspective to consider is that your manager is possibly trying to give you the opportunity to meet compliance standards instead of just replacing you out of hand.

    You could also appeal to your supervisor's boss. The worst thing that can happen is that they will tell you the same thing your boss is telling you now.

    I know it stinks but "using" willing employees is a practice as old as time. You have put in all of the extra work and the people who work beside and above you know it, but it doesn't change the fact that hindsight is 20/20 and you should have demanded more pay and a title change as soon as those extra duties were handed off to you.

    If all else fails and you can't stay there, just think of all of the extra skills and confidence you've acquired in the role without meaning to! Take those amazing skills and put them to use in a place where you will be welcomed and appreciated! Good luck!

  3. Nancy Geller

    First of all, I think you're amazing.
    Amazing for taking on responsibilities that you were not trained for nor interested in!! You rose to the challenge, and they are idiots for not recognizing how valuable you are to both the organization and more importantly, to the morale of everyone you talk to, encounter, etc. That being said, I STRONGLY believe you should harness the skills that you've picked up with your amazingness and pursue Transportation at another organization. It doesn't need to be a school - you could transfer these skills to a Trucking company, cab company, et al - there are opportunities you could pursue at companies that understand and value what you've done. You are worthy, you are valuable, you are amazing for having done all this with zero support. Take a deep breath, re-write your resume and get on Indeed or whatever else, type in transportation and let yourself loose!!!! You go, girl.

  4. Anonymous

    Not surprised. It is a lesson, never actually care about the job. It sounds like you really did care...staying late, so much more.

    You have a few choices here.

    1. File EEOC, as you have a disability that is an impediment to doing the CDL class.

    2. Take the CDL class, suck it up.

    3. Say nothing, look for another job.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members