I work in finance and have been very focused on advancement and motivated to get promoted.

I work in finance and have been very focused on advancement and motivated to get promoted. In the last year with my company, which has also been my first year, I worked really hard to go above and beyond, as well as take on a great deal of project management work which was not in my job description as I’m in a sales role. Additionally, I’ve joined my company’s women’s forum and other employee leadership groups. On top of that, my client coverage doubled when other salespeople left and were not replaced. I really enjoy my job and am great with my new clients and old clients— I started asking my manager about what I need to do to be considered for promotion and didn’t get a clear answer. He also doesn’t really believe in the annual review process and doesn’t take providing feedback seriously. He’s never managed anyone before and doesn’t know the promotion process either. His manager has been great with me and I’m considering asking if I can report directly to him since he was the direct manager of the other salespeople who left (whose clients I have taken over).

I was also told by a male colleague that in order to get promoted, I need to be very clear and basically say “I will do xyz task, which will take a large burden off your shoulders, and in return, you will put me up for promotion.”

There is a big project coming up for which I have been asked to take on more outside of my normal job description to lead the launch of the project, which is to sell a new product. Should I approach my manager and his manager with the way my male colleague suggested? I just feel like my manager has no idea what is worthy of promotion, and gives me no direction, and I did a ton of work last year that was not recognized. Now I want to have a clear path to the kind of tasks/responsibilities I need to do to be considered for promotion, and if they can’t tell me what those tasks are, then I will make suggestions and ask them if these projects are— because if they are not, I don’t want to continue to do extra work that isn’t recognized or rewarded.

But I’m not sure how that will come off and how to phrase this in an effective and elegant way.

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

3 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Barb Hansen

    It's always good (and it never hurts) to get as much information as you can about what it takes to get promoted at your company:

    - ask other close colleagues in the company about their promotion journey
    - ask your manager what a promotion path looks like in this department
    - talk to HR (if you can)

    Once you have as much information as you can gather, then have a specific conversation with your manager about what steps you need to take to get a promotion.

    Your male colleague may be telling you the right path for everyone at the company OR he may be telling you the path that worked for him.

    I'm a huge fan of being direct, asking for what you want and creating a path that works for you, but I'm also a fan of having more than just one source of information when you build your plan.

  2. Anonymous

    A direct and honest conversation usually works best with people who are not as focused or aware of these types of issues. I would summarize your extra projects taken on, your history of any commendations or compliments from clients, etc. Ask your their thoughts on further efforts required for a promotion and the time-line to set expectations.

  3. Pat Roque

    You’ll need to clearly build a business case , documenting your quantifiable accomplishments, responsibilities and the areas that benefit from each.

    Was it a team building/leadership win? Saved the company tine? Earned —$$ more money? Hard skills snd doft skills used.

    Get written recommendations on LinkedIn whenever a colleague or client thanks you for a job well done.

    If you’re not comfortable managing up to get agreement on your roadmap From your current manager, work with HR and your boss’ boss if you must. Be direct yet diplomatic, a strong team player who documents and articulates your value.

    You can do it! ??

    Please reach out if you have questions, this can positively impact the rest of your career! With compound benefits over many years. ?

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members