No, it isn’t a joke to employers, but I can share insight on what’s going on.
I am speaking from my own experience as an internal recruiter at a startup with a broken hiring process.
The market has shifted to the benefit of the employers who are receiving hundreds of resumes from top tier candidates, when before, you would source and hope someone would have a modicum of interest in your company.
The recruiting teams (internal) are short staffed. To save money, companies run lean and have one recruiter, maybe a sourcer, and no coordinator. Add in a bunch of requisitions, a junior hiring team that has zero clue into interviewing effectively—The feedback is comical, if you ever receive feedback. Sometimes, you have to chase after interviewers to have them submit feedback, which could take weeks.
Example: A highly regarded team member said they could support the team by taking on interviews. However, they never submitted their feedback on the three interviews they did. After two follow-ups from myself, two from my manager, and three from his own manager—nothing! Ridiculous! That’s a piss poor experience for the candidate. They don’t care, because recruiters get the hate, not them.
To add, because companies have the advantage, they can be “picky” and interview candidates until they feel they have found the best one. A candidate can interview very well and be a strong fit, but if they happened to be the first person to make final rounds, it’ll be a waiting game. You know why? Because they will want to interview few more people to receive additional datapoints to be “sure” they are making the right hire, thus delaying the process further.
Throw in incompetent hiring managers that have no idea how to run a clean process, partner with the recruiter and identify the ideal profile until they speak with a few dozen candidates. They also do not know how to write a proper job description.
So, there might be some game playing after all. It is indeed frustrating from the candidate’s pov. That’s why I’m upfront with my candidates and share the good, bad and the ugly, so you can make an informed decision. I know my company is a shit-show. I could write my own blog about the crap I’ve dealt with after 2.5 years, but I digress.
One last thing, there are some shitty recruiters out there. Many are indeed narcissistic, lack attention to detail and are dealing with so many openings, they allow people to slip through the cracks. I’ve worked at both enterprise companies and startups and have seen it all. No matter how much we push for answers, feedback, to improve process, etc., you’re going against inexperience employees that have never interviewed, or are forced to interview while working 60 hour weeks to deliver a product, and couldn’t care less about the process or you. You could also be dealing with a manager that wants to screen 100 people because they do not trust themselves or their team to make a good hire.
Share your insight
Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.
61 Comments
Join the conversation