I agree with other posters that this may be a good time to take advantage of a lower workload and start looking for other jobs. If you are committed to staying, I don't think that this is 100% a lost cause....but may not be worth the work that it would take for your new supervisor to trust you
Your story struck me as somewhat similar to a situation I am currently in- although in this case, I am the manager. While I hope that your situation is different, I think that it might be helpful to share my perspective... I manage a small team of 3 and one is, simply put, much lower performing than the others. I inherited him from a previous manager with much lower standards and
nearly all of my interactions with him have been "coaching moments" when I discover mistakes in their work or see opportunities for improvement. He requires a lot of handholding on any new project, makes a lot of mistakes and the output is just generally very mediocre. He also took a lot of time off last year for personal reasons (I don’t hold this against him specifically, but it does contribute to an overall impression of not being very competent/motivated)
After getting burned a couple of times, I now assign nearly all new requests to the other team members or would rather just take it on myself. It’s not worth the time to walk through the details steps that have to be done, only to receive work back that needs to be thoroughly checked and in many cases redone. The other team members have easily 5x as much work as him, but they don’t want to give him anything for the same reason- we cannot trust the output of the lower performer, and even if the work is technically done according to the request, it is never as good as it could be. Unfortunately, he probably does not realize this since he has always been an individual contributor and in positions where it seems he was never held to a very high standard. Coaching has not really helped
In our 1:1s, I have outright questioned whether he is suited to this position, and have encouraged him to look for positions on other teams. Frankly, I think that everyone on the team, including himself, would be better off if he found a position that suited his strengths better. Again, I hope that your situation is different, but I hope this gives you an additional perspective of what could be happening. I think its worth having an honest conversation with your manager to come up with a plan of how to turn things around.
Share your insight
Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.
23 Comments
Join the conversation