Hey recruiters, are cover letters *really* necessary?

Hey recruiters, are cover letters *really* necessary?

I consider myself a good writer, but whenever I write a cover letter it just feels so underwhelming and stocky and boring—and not me. Do you really read them? Be honest. And if do, what are the unique elements that make it stand out?

Signed,

Someone who hates cover letters

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

13 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Barb Hansen

    As a hiring manager, I don't read cover letters (if provided by an applicant).

    I don't think cover letters are an indication of a quality applicant. Cover letters are an indication on how well a person can write (and sometimes write fiction) or how well the person can edit a cover letter template that they found on the web.

    I would rather an applicant follow up with a meaningful and insightful email after the interview.

    I'm looking forward to hear what recruiters say to this.

  2. Tracey Morris

    I have been in talent acquisition for most of my career and -- total transparency -- unless the hiring manager has specifically requested that candidates provide a cover letter, I rarely read them. If I have a question about why a person is applying to a position or I have two similarly qualified candidates, I might review the letter to see if there is a differentiator there. But that is a rare exception.

    Some reasons to include a cover letter: significant career shift -- either in type of job or level of responsibility; relocation -- trying to move to a new city/town; a unique, niche or significant skillset -- something related to the requirements for the job that could be a differentiator.

    I hope this helps! Best of luck with your search.

  3. Anonymous

    I am not a fan of them either, but I use the wording below if I have to send one with my resume.

    I am submitting my resume in response to your job posting for a/an (job title). This position sounds like an excellent match with my background, and I would welcome the opportunity to discuss it further with you.

    My Matching qualifications are as follows:
    -10 years of .....experience
    -BA in .......
    -5 years of.....experience
    -Highly proficient in .....

    Should you agree that my credentials are a suitable match for your requirements, I would greatly appreciate the chance to further explore this opportunity through an interview. You can reach me during the day, on a confidential basis, at (xxx) xxx-xxxx.

    Thank you for your consideration, and I look forward to hearing from you.

  4. Anonymous

    I can share having been a corporate recruiter for 11 years I rarely looked at them.

    Same as Tracey, sometimes I would review cover letters because they can help to address questions that someone might have looking at your resume if that is applicable. Tracey gave some good examples to consider.

  5. Anonymous

    I'm not a recruiter but as a hiring manager, I only read cover letters if I'm 'borderline' on a resume meeting the qualifications.

  6. Arlene Frances Gottardo (Bryak)

    Ask someone to read it.

  7. Joan Williams, Senior Talent Acquisition Specialist

    Every time I post this, I get blasted but here's my two cents as a recruiter with over 20 years experience.

    I rarely, if ever, read cover letters. My hiring managers don't read cover letters.

    Cover letters are opinion pieces. Resumes are factual documents. A CL is never going to make someone who is not a fit for my position be a fit.

  8. Claudia

    In state work, you have a state app (that is essentially the same info as a resume) so we rely on your cover letter to tell us things we can't find out otherwise.

    I always read the cover letters, though we have folks answer questions in a writing assignment as well, which is way more useful than a cover letter tbh.

    I guess I just prefer them both!

  9. Anonymous

    From hiring perspective:

    "I only read cover letters if I'm 'borderline' on a resume meeting the qualifications" summarizes it all in 1 sentence. Sometime we are looking at marginals even prior to Interview Round 1.

    From candidate perspective:

    The cover letter gives the person time to actually consider why applying for the position - so one could argue that it is more a mental process for the candidate. But it is also an opportunity to provide hiring manager and company that extra argument for why the person is best choice.

    To "Someone who hates cover letters" - if you find the cover letter too stocky and boring; it sounds like you are applying without being at full heart with the position nor the company. Maybe not finding motivation for writing a cover letter is your indicator that this is neither the position nor the company you should apply for ?

  10. Anonymous

    I wasn't a fan of writing them either but I would say that 75% of the jobs I applied to required them on the application. It was irritating, I wrote a lot of cover letters. I will say I work in Career Counseling so maybe that's why.

    I always tell my students - if its required you obviously have to write it. Will they read it, I don't know but they want it.

    If it isn't or is optional - they probably won't read it. This isn't every person obviously but based on the comments below a lot of hiring managers/recruiters don't.

  11. Tomilyn Richards

    NOPE!! =)

  12. Lauren

    Most do not. Unless you are seeking a role within a nonprofit which would allow you to express your connection to the org's mission or if you are utilizing transferrable skills to enter into another industry. Otherwise, don't waste your time.

  13. Anonymous

    I'd say it depends on the role and the field. I always read cover letters. The higher the position, and the more "traditional" the field, the more likely a cover letter will make a difference. As someone else noted, a good cover letter isn't going to make an unqualified person suddenly qualified, but it can add to the selection process and there are people I've interviewed because of what was in their cover letter but not necessarily well-presented in their resume. I have also dodged bullets - one cover letter (from someone I'd invited to apply for the position) talked about how much he wanted to get away from one particular person in his current department. 1) No negativity, even if invited. And 2) the position I was hiring for had almost daily contact with that person and had to work effectively with them.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members