Hey ladies! I need some advice since this is definitely a pros and cons situation. Sorry in advance for the long post..

Hey ladies! I need some advice since this is definitely a pros and cons situation. Sorry in advance for the long post..

Situation: My company had hired me as remote/ work from home status over a couple years ago, but is now requiring everyone to come into the office 10

days each month for the full week every other week, regardless of hire letter status. I am totally fine with going into the office, however, my teams are in Boston or Raleigh, which are clearly not commutable distances from Philadelphia, where I live.

We cannot move because we have a physical family business and also a small child. Going to these required locations for a week at a time would take me to be away from my family basically about 50% of the time. This travel would also be on my own expense as with anyone else’s “normal commute”.

Because of this, I decided that I will voluntarily leave my position by the end of the year and take the severance package that they are offering me since they changed the employment location on me, and this pays me until June next year (6 months of salary).

Options: I work at a very large company, and another part of the business has a role they created for me that can report out of Jersey City, which is the closest home office location that I am allowed to report to (my current role does not allow this due to my teams being elsewhere above). They offered me the role which includes an elevated title and level, higher base salary by about $35k, and higher target bonus percentage increase by 50%, which in total should slightly more than cover the additional cost of travel/ Amtrak, childcare, and other expenses going to Jersey City 10 days each month, after tax etc. I should also note that the other part of the business created this role for me and got the level raised knowing that the commute would be difficult and wanted to make this more appealing so I could stay at the company.

I am also actively interviewing for other roles that would pay me around the same amount or more, but where I can commute within an hour in our region vs. 2 hours each way. However, I do not have firm offers in hand yet to compare, even though I’ve been having conversations with higher level executives at these companies, as things move slow as expected.

I should get back to my current company and the new role they offered me this week to let them know of my decision.

I am feeling pretty optimistic about the other options that are local or remote, and I don’t want to sacrifice my well-being as well as my family’s well-being. But I also don’t want to give up a good opportunity that was given to me, and risk that I might not have any new options as the new year rolls around as I know the job market can be tricky as the new year and new administration comes in.

Other wrench: we are trying to have another child, and I could be pregnant within the next year if all goes well. I am already vested and eligible for all benefits etc here at my current company. And I would need to potentially be looking for a new role while being pregnant or soon after, maybe not qualifying for leave, etc.

What would you do??

Thank you in advance!

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

24 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Anonymous

    How long have you been with your current company? How are the benefits compared to potential new employers? What does your maternity leave/parental leave policy look like where you are? Are you generally happy there?

  2. Anonymous

    I have been with my company about 2.5 years, and honestly the benefits and pay here are competitive and hard to come by! Also my tenure from my previous job (a subsidiary of this one) carried over so I qualify for the highest amount of PTO on top of vesting and other benefits that come along with tenure that long. I have 12 weeks of paid maternity leave and short term disability/ FMLA too. I’m also generally happy here! People are nice :)

  3. Anonymous

    Thanks for responding! I think...unless there is something I am missing here, it would make complete sense to take the offer from your current employer.

  4. Anonymous

    I would take the new offer with your company because A. you are already vested, B. it's more secure than the unknown from other companies, and C. you already know the parental benefits in the current company, and finally, D. you are a known resource and are very fortunate they value you enough to make a new role for you. That is amazing! Then if you do have another child, you have a network of a company that already supports you, and perhaps after another 2 year mark consider working somewhere that is closer. However, if your goal is to have another child, it's important to be closer to home. If you are expected to give your answer this week, and you do not have any other offers to weigh, I vote for staying with your same company for now. The market is so volatile right now that having an offer like that, more money, not that far away, and a better title, aligns you for bigger and better later. Do let us know what happens! Good luck to you!

  5. Anonymous

    I would definitely consider staying with this company for the time being.

  6. JB09718

    Difficult situation with a lot of variables. Personally, would accept the transfer role at current company but maintain a good relationship with the other companies you’re interviewing with. I would not want to risk losing any benefits, family leave, etc. if I was pregnant. Not to mention, if they created the position for you they want to make you happy so you stay. If you try it out and it doesn’t work out, revisit with them and see if they’re willing to make any additional accommodations. (One family I nannied for let the mom bring her newborn with to the office for a couple months, not that this would work for everyone but companies can be flexible and creative with solutions if they really want to!)

  7. Anonymous

    Based on reading a lot of other posts on this site, most companies don’t even offer maternity leave until after you have been with them for a year. So if you wait and take a new job, you might not even be eligible to take leave. I would stay at this new company, tough it out for a bit. If you get pregnant you can always try to negotiate less days in the office until the baby’s comes. Keep looking for other jobs and interviewing, but be aware of their leave policies before taking any offers.

  8. Anonymous

    Have you looked at the train schedules to verify that they will get you to Jersey City and back in a timeframe that balances your home life and work requirements? If you have, and that's the pricing you are looking at, I would take the internal job, as they have bent over backward and value you as an employee. As one familiar with the trains in that area, make sure you are comparing the correct train schedules because Amtrac, Septa, and the trains into New Jersey have different schedules and huge variations in pricing.

  9. misskelleyp

    Take the job being offered by your current company. Then keep your options open. If something better comes up that offers the benefits you're looking for, no one can blame you for doing what's best for you and your family.

  10. Julie E

    I would take the job with your current company but still keep talking with the others. If one of the others come through, quit the one with your current company. Thank them for the opportunity but tell them another offer came through that’s a better fit for your family with a shorter commute. They have to understand things like this are going to happen when they change the rules of the game and suddenly start requiring return to office when you never went to an office.

  11. Carmen Honacker

    What the first person said! Absolutely take the job, but keep searching until you have a better offer and then leave. Also, make sure to research what any new company offers in terms of materinity leave, etc. For bigger companies this information floats about online. If it isn't mentioned in any new offer, be careful how you are asking it.

  12. Milissa Jacobs

    It seems my advice has been given. Take the offer and keep looking for something that better suits your needs.

  13. Vidya Bhat

    I think when the company made that decision to call people to work in person there has to be a reason behind it. They are very much aware of the location of the people working remotely. Either the company wants t reduce the head count or if that is not the reason then if an employee genuienly can not make it to the work place may give him/her an option. One always has an option to look for an alternative as a last resort.

  14. Anonymous

    I agree with this. OP should discuss with her mgmt b4 leaving as its been my experience that the ppl they want to keep they will work with

  15. Anonymous

    a "bird in hand is worth two in the bush". Take the Jersey City position and meanwhile keep your eyes wide open for another possible opportunity closer to home. There are alot of "what ifs" and other possibiities we won't know (you may or may not get pregnant right away, you "could" move slightly closer to Jersey City, you might have work days in Jersey City cancelled due to inclement weather, you "might" need PTO due to illness or other FMLA emergency)- you've been treated well where you're at- so I would stay with the employer for now...

  16. Ayian

    Accept the position you have been offered and continue interviewing. If you have a comparable offer after interviewing, you can decide then.

    Alternatively, ask for another two weeks to make your decision, as it is a major life change for you and your family.

  17. Anonymous

    As a former commuter of 2 hours in traffic each way, knowing what I know now I would not take it. You miss so much of life. My whole day was work centered, by the time I got home it was time to go to bed, get up and do it all over again.

  18. Heather Haaland

    This is such a tough decision. It sounds like a good career advancement and a lot of positions at a certain point require you to be in person. If you don’t take the position are you going to resent not taking the career advancement at this time?

    At the same time, you need to do what is best for you and your family.

    Commuting four hours a days essentially half the working days a month is a lot of precious time away from you small kiddos and if you have a baby that could mean leaving before childcare opens up and not getting home until after they are closed. Is this a feasible scenario with owning a small business? Do you want to spend this time away from your kiddos?

  19. Anonymous

    Perhaps I am not the best person to answer this as I am 67 and retired . But, these days I spend a considerable amount of time thinking how short the time I had with my kids and now my grandson, being little. I would never say don't work. It is important to have your own money and career. But, if I could have found a job that allowed me to at least stay stable in my career and go home at 5, I would have done that

  20. Sandra Swearingen

    Take the other job offer. In a new job you start from the bottom. It sounds like they value you and are willing to work with you. That is worth a lot.

  21. Anonymous

    What if you took the role in your existing company and requested, as part of your negotiation, a 3- month and 6- month check in discussion to see how everything is working for the company and you. You might find that once you earn the trust in the new role that there might be some flexibility allowed related to the required in office time.

  22. Anonymous

    My company has a policy on what is considered a commutable distance. Its 60 miles and it is regardless of the travel time.

    i think you could find a way to ask about that. Perhaps your manager does not know. Or perhaps they know and are choosing not to make that apparent (like it becomes the employees job to find out) so that there is attrition on purpose.

  23. Anonymous

    If pregnant you can file for accommodations for remote work if you meet the criteria. I’m not sure what the criteria is.

  24. Anonymous

    I live in Philly and have been faced with the same situation. Any employer who expects you to

    commute 2 hours is unreasonable. And, even if you have a handshake agreement with your current/upcoming boss, that changes based on climate. I don’t think you’re saying that’s on the table but, my point is I think it is best to go with things that are concrete. Like commute distance/time. It will give you some sense of normalcy. I have commuted 2.5 hours by public transit and when a train is late, or there are weather delays it can quickly become 3-3.5 hours. If stability is what you need, perhaps prioritize that option. It might offer some peace of mind for all involved.

Browse recent posts

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members