Undervalued

I bust my butt at work. My performance reports are good. Unfortunately, I believe I have made an enemy in upper management who is making it impossible for me to get a promotion. I am not given credit for what I do even though I have developed / onboarded solutions that have greatly contributed to the effectiveness of the unit.

Recently, an outsider was hired. This outsider came in, took my staff, and promoted many of them to my level or above. The outsider tried to get me promoted but was denied.

Any advice on how to navigate this? I love my role, the organization, and the benefits. I really don't want to look for another job. I am absolutely mystified on why promotions seem to be blocked for me. I don't know what I have done.

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

24 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Anonymous

    Sorry, I don't have any advice. Just wanted to say you are not alone. When you walk into the room, have you noticed anyone from Upper Management rolling their eyes - before you even speak?

  2. Anonymous

    I would recommend reaching out directly to upper management and seeing what you can do to fix things. Sometimes communicating your passion for the company and desire to move forward can clear up reservations. Otherwise, it sounds like you might have to move companies to get ahead.

  3. Jennifer Anderson
    My husband encountered this problem and I will tell you what I told him. Promotions aren't always about aptitude and are often about politics. It sounds like your work ethic and work is above reproach, your boss tried to get your promoted. That's a good sign. Unfortunately, something you did in the past didn't go over well and it's left a bad taste in someone's mouth. Learning how to 'play politics' is just as important as learning how to do your job well. Hubby's problem is that he is a long term strategic thinker and he scares all the employees around him because he constantly wants to implement new things. His ideas aren't bad but note that I said "he scares people". Another friend that works in Silicon Valley is a powerhouse. She is awesome and I think could solve most of the worlds problems. Unfortunately, she pissed off most of her management because she is willing to call a bad idea a bad idea whether in a public or private conversations. She is faithful, loyal and unfortunately loud and opinionated. I would offer two suggestions for you. 1. If your new boss is willing, ask if they can help you improve your image. Have a critical conversation and be willing to listen to what they say. Create a concrete plan to address these issues. 2. Read the following: Crucial Conversations: Tools for Talking When Stakes Are High by by Kerry Patterson (Author), Joseph Grenny (Author), Ron McMillan (Author), Al Switzler (Author) and The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People: Powerful Lessons in Personal Change by Steven Covey Hubby read both of these and used the tools from both to turn things around. In less than a year, he has gone from not being invited to meetings, his ideas being ignored, and being passed over for a promotion to being a thought leader, being sought out for advice and hopefully (fingers crossed) getting a promotion at work that will advance him to the next level. His problem, you see, wasn't his performance, it was his idea delivery and communication skills. Good Luck!
  4. Anonymous

    Oh boy, I sound like your husband. Maybe that is the issue. I am very innovative and also forthright on my opinions.

    Thanks for the advice. That is extremely helpful. I don't "do politics" very well.

  5. BansheeBailey

    It’s an art, for sure. But it involves learnable skills. Sometimes you just have to bite your tongue (or at least postpone speaking right away), make an appearance at the office party you’d rather skip, schmooze people whose cooperation you will need, etc.

  6. Anonymous

    this is so helpful, i think i'm going to get this book too. thanks for sharing.

  7. Anonymous

    I understand that "playing" politics is important, but do any of you ever wonder why we also don't require people to work on not being scared by people who have something to say and take initiative to achieve it?

    By not doing so, we propagate the idea that strong, Type A, passionate, effective people need to dial it down for the comfort of every individual insecurity each person in the room holds.

    I wish we taught each person to manage their own. Did that guy's really great idea make you realize that you didn't know as much as you think you did? Great. Now you know and can manage it. Don't make it his responsibility to dance around you so you never feel uncomfortable again.

    Think of what more we could have accomplished as a people if we could speak directly and honestly to each other and then just. keep. moving.

  8. Logan

    One other book suggestion: Conversational Intelligence by Judith Glaser. I am a certified Conversational Intelligence (C-IQ) coach and had the amazing opportunity to study directly with Judith before she passed away. C-IQ provides a lot of very practical tools for navigating the neuroscience of conversation and for repairing relationships. I hope this helps!

  9. Rose Holland

    Great advice above! Does your company have a Mentor program? This might be a great way to overcome your issues as well. I have a coworker who had a reputation as immature from when she first started fresh out of college. Our senior leaders are involved with our program and her participating helped overcome that old impression.

  10. Six Figure Salary Coach

    Hey - this is really strange, and also intriguing.....

    The outsider that tried to have you promoted, do you have a good relationship with this person? How did you learn that this request was denied? I am interested if you can learn more about WHY.

    Do you have any idea what may have happened that you have an 'enemy'? Do you know who the 'enemy' is?

    I work with women to help them craft their own promotions and take control of their career - if you are will to grab the bull by the horns at work :) More often than not, we need to push a little. It's all about building a strong business case (business being the operative word here) to help pave your own way instead of waiting for someone else to give you a promotion.

    Having opinions and ideas are GOOD - it helps companies grow. But, it's all about the presentation. Sometimes it's an art form. I coach on the right way to present your ideas so you are focusing on the business, and not on yourself (or the 'negatives'). It takes some practice - but it's easy to do once you have the right foundation.

    I am very interested to learn more about what's going on above you to see if we can strategize a way through it!

  11. Anonymous

    I have a decent relationship with this person. However, there is no doubt that the boss has been influenced from above. The boss won't elaborate, but has intimated that I may have upset someone. I know for a fact that my boss's boss has an issue with me. Once my boss's boss got a big promotion a few years back, I got dumped. That's when it all started. This person has discouraged me from doing anything to advance and has even pulled the rug out from me on projects. I feel actively undermined. I have gone to the boss's boss several times with no satisfaction. In fact, a psychologist I work with once called this person a "psychopath." So, I really feel like I don't stand a chance unless this person leaves. It is really a sad situation. b

  12. Six Figure Salary Coach

    Yes, this individual does sound very malicious and internationally disruptive to your career. He/she could very well be a psychopath which is so unfortunate.

    Do you know if other people have the same experiences?

  13. Anonymous

    Actually, it is funny that you should say that. I worked with a psychologist and authority (writer) who diagnosed this person as a "psychopath." I was advised to have a plan b. The problem is, I really like the organization for which I work. I like the work I do, which is not a common position that I could just leave. I like the flexibility. I like the personal ties. *sigh* Frustrating...

  14. Anonymous

    Yes, this person demoted someone and took over 10k from their pay when they formed the business unit. In order to do so, the person was falsely maligned in their performance review.

  15. Marie N

    I do not have any clear guidance/advice. I went through the enemy in management for many years and she definitely held up my promotions. Every one that knew me told me she did it. I just hung in there proving myself and when this enemy finally was out of her position, I was promoted almost immediately. If I had to go through my career all over again, perhaps I would have been stronger and stood up for myself a little better or moved on to something else. Good Luck!

  16. Anonymous

    It is embarrassing, yet oddly reassuring, to have people from other departments come to you privately to question the moves that the organization made in regard to your career and assure you that they see something wrong as well.

  17. Anonymous

    Thanks everyone. The comments have been very helpful. I think many of you are correct. I really stink at playing politics.

  18. Anonymous

    Is it possible that when your boss's boss got that big promotion a couple years back that someone may have mentioned to them that they had also considered you for the promotion at the time but then ultimately gave it to your boss's boss? If you can't think of anything you have done to directly antagonize this person, perhaps they just see you as a direct threat to their own position and don't want you climbing any higher. They may have information that you don't have. Perhaps their higher up mentioned being impressed with you and they are trying to shut that down.

  19. Anonymous

    I doubt that, however my work was a huge part of the promotion I am sure. I made this person look good. I am more and more convinced that this person doesn't like me for some reason. That reason remains a mystery. I used to be this person right-hand.

  20. Anonymous

    I cringe at how much pull people "try" to have over you moving up the ladder at work. Being as though you enjoy the job I would seek as to why you are being blocked from promotion I think it's only right to let someone know why they aren't being promoted so that they can work on it and try again later. The guessing game is not fun and you couldn't have made someone that mad because you are still working for the company. I wouldn't spend a lot of energy on this if no explanation is given ultimately you are the ruler of how you move forward with your success :))

  21. Anonymous

    Right? I have inquired at length and received not one satisfactory response. The fact that I applied for a senior level position only to have this person take me to lunch to discourage me is still unbelievable to me. As someone's manager, shouldn't you be supportive and offer advice that is helpful rather than stinging one liners like "You are not a leader?" That tells me absolutely nothing.

  22. Anonymous

    They should absolutely! Be supportive! People will try and discourage you throughout your life because of their own hang ups. You are valued more than you know or you would not be there. You have no idea what’s being said behind closed doors which is a good thing or you would probably take you talents somewhere else. I'd say we are close to a new a fresh beginning of the New Year. Keep us updated on if they change their mind if they don't it’s ok for you to change your mind on them! I wish you much success!

  23. Anonymous

    Thank you for all your support everyone. I truly appreciate it.

  24. Anonymous

    The only way to change something - is to confront management directly, asking why those things are happening. Might be also good to talk to HR before I guess.

    If promotions are blocked, but you don't want to look for a new job - just kickback and relax. Do your bare minimum(not like you're going to get promoted anyway). Spend more time with your family or find a hobby(For example I've recently picked up target shooting thanks to https://blog.gritrsports.com/ and it's been a whole load of fun!).

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members