I currently have no savings (aside from my 401k). This is why:
My husband and I have about $440k USD in debt, with $150k in mortgage, $150k in school loans, $70k in auto loans, $35k in personal loans (prior debt consolidation), $25k on credit cards, and $10k in medical debt.
^^THAT is all an emergency. I need ^^THAT all gone.
So until I am out of debt, or nearly out of debt, I will not be keeping $1000 in a savings account, earning $1.75 per month (2.5% yearly interest), and paying $12.17 in interest on that same $1000 on a credit card with the interest rate of 14.6%.
I am a Dave Ramsey and Suze Orman fan. They usually agree on most money matters. They disagree on the $1000 emergency fund, and I agree with Suze on this one -- what's the point of paying more in interest every month to "feel secure" when I could Really Be Secure more quickly if I just paid the $1000 toward my debt and stopped incurring interest on it?
We could keep the $1000 *in case* something happens, and keep paying the interest on the debts... or we could pay that off a card, and *if* something happens, put the $1000 on a card (which we'd ideally have gotten our interest rate lowered on by then).
So for example, assuming $10,000 on Credit Card w/ 14.6% interest rate, $500 monthly debt snowball, and $1000 in the bank with a 2.5% interest rate, and during Month 5, a $500 emergency:
Starting Net Value: $9000
(Following lines go in this order: Debt Balance, Card Interest, Principal Payment, Savings Balance, Bank Interest, Net Value)
Month 1 w/ EF: $10000, $121.67, $378.33, $1000, $2.08, -$8619.59 (w/ EF)
Month 2 w/ EF: $9621.67, $117.06, $382.94, $1002.08, $2.09, -$8234.56 (w/ EF)
Month 3 w/ EF: $9238.73, $112.40, $387.60, $1004.17, $2.09, -$7844.87 (w/ EF)
Month 4 w/ EF: $8851.13, $107.69, $392.31, $1006.26, $2.10, -$7450.46 (w/ EF)
Month 5 w/ EF: $8458.82, $102.92, $397.08, $508.36, $1.06, -$7552.32 (w/ EF)
Month 6 w/ EF: $8061.74, $98.08, $0, $910.28, $1.90, -$7149.56 (w/ EF)
Month 7 w/ EF: $8061.74, $98.08, $312.2, $1000, $2.08, -$6747.46 (w/ EF)
Month 8 w/ EF: $7749.54, $94.29, $405.71, $1002.08, $2.09, -$6339.66 (w/ EF)
Month 9 w/ EF: $7343.83, $89.35, $410.65, $1004.17, $2.09, -$5926.92 (w/ EF)
Month 10 w/ EF: $6933.18, $84.35, $415.65, $1006.26, $2.10, -$5509.17 (w/ EF)
Month 11 w/ EF: $6517.53, $79.30, $420.70, $1008.36, $2.10, -$5086.37 (w/ EF)
Month 12 w/ EF: $6096.83, $74.18, $425.82, $1010.46, $2.11, -$4658.44 (w/ EF)
Month 1 w/o EF: $9000, $109.50, $390.50, $0, $0, -$8609.50 (w/o EF)
Month 2 w/o EF: $8609.50, $104.75, $395.25, $0, $0, -$8214.25 (w/o EF)
Month 3 w/o EF: $8214.25, $99.94, $400.06, $0, $0, -$7814.19 (w/o EF)
Month 4 w/o EF: $7814.19, $95.07, $404.93, $0, $0, -$7409.26 (w/o EF)
Month 5 w/o EF: $7909.26, $96.23, $403.77, $0, $0, -$7505.49 (w/o EF)
Month 6 w/o EF: $7505.49, $91.32, $408.68, $0, $0, -$7096.81 (w/o EF)
Month 7 w/o EF: $7096.81, $86.34, $413.66, $0, $0, -$6683.15 (w/o EF)
Month 8 w/o EF: $6683.15, $81.31, $418.69 , $0, $0, -$6264.46 (w/o EF)
Month 9 w/o EF: $6264.46, $76.22, $423.78, $0, $0, -$5840.68 (w/o EF)
Month 10 w/o EF: $5840.68, $71.06, $428.94, $0, $0, -$5411.74 (w/o EF)
Month 11 w/o EF: $5411.74, $65.84, $434.16, $0, $0, -$4977.58 (w/o EF)
Month 12 w/o EF: $4977.58, $60.56, $439.44, $0, $0, -$4538.14 (w/o EF)
End of Year Total Net Value w/ EF: -$4658.44
End of Year Total Net Value w/o EF: -$4538.14
Difference: $120.30
My husband and I have gone through A LOT of trials the last three years (spiritual, moral, relational, and legal), and we've already dug ourselves out of more than half our debt. But we've got a long way to go, and our feeling is that pseudo security of $1000 in the bank but not in our wallets won't get us out of debt any quicker. An extra $120.30 per year *will*, especially when you consider that because of the mentality that $120 a year makes a difference, we probably make a lot of other decisions which add up to way more than $120 a year.
Share your insight
Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.
24 Comments
Join the conversation