How do you choose between job offers?

How do you choose between job offers?

Today I received job offers from not one, but two companies. Company A is a company I have worked for before. I asked my former manager to recommend me as I wanted to posaibly go back and he did really great in speking to all the decision makers to secure me a place. I had only one interview with my future manager, we clicked well. When I worked for this company before I totally loved it. I had a lot of work, but my efforts were always appreciated. I had great reputation even within the senior leadership team and the CEO team. Everyone knew my name and my word was always trusted. I left due to personal reasons and now an year later that I am in search for a job it was natural to re-apply there.

The other company, let's call it company B looks like an interesting place.to work but extremely process oriented. From what I heard in the interview they blindely follow processes, which bothers me because I like the opportunity to improve and optimize the work process. Work as a volume might be much less than in company A, and the salary is much better.

With what both offers provide I can pay my bills and maintain my standard of life which is good. If money were not a factor I would always choose company A, but with the money factor I am in doubt. Should I listen to my heart and ignore the money?

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

10 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Kelly Walsh Heier

    Listen to your heart.

  2. Alicia Picone

    I think your post answers your own question.

  3. Tamara Thompson

    I agree with both comments... but a 3rd option, what about letting them know of the other offer and see if they can come up in salary at all? Couldn't hurt to ask, but then I agree- listen to your heart- but try to get a little extra first ;)

  4. Vesela Krasteva

    Thank you so much for this advice! I will try this 3rd option. I like it.

  5. Anonymous

    I always do an apples to apples comparison first comparing

    1. Salary, benefits, 401k, bonuses, other financial offsets.

    2. Location/travel time

    3. Remote/hybrid opportunity

    4. Career path

    Once I compare those items I check my gut and emotional connection and my work/life balance offered

    You should weigh career, lifestyle and overall comfort offered by each.

  6. Anonymous

    Working with the familiar may be comforting to an extent but growth requires you to stretch a little. If my vote helps-B! Congratulations on getting 2 offers!!! ☺️

  7. Anonymous

    2 offers is amazing and very validating fir sure. It sounds like your comfortable returning to your former employer but there might be an issue with their compensation. I would let them know that another offer was higher and more in line with current the current market trends for the position.

  8. Eva Steortz

    I have never heard of one success story when someone chooses a job just because of the money.

    List out all of the things important to you and rate each on a one to five scale for both jobs. Culture. Learning. Commute. Advancement Potential. Leadership. Industry I Like etc. I have found doing the math helps shed light. Use this plus your heart. Good luck!!!

  9. Sabrina Cortes

    Yes, write out all of the pros and cons of each mentioned above. This will help you think more objectively. Then, listen to your heart. :)

  10. Anonymous

    Listen to your heart, especially if the salary at Company A is a step up from your current job.

    But before that: Tell Company A that you have received a simultaneous offer from B, and ask if A can improve its offer.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members