When to throw in the towel

I've been at my current job for 2 1/2 years. About 6 months in, one of my team members left and I've been filling in for the role ever since with no additional pay, title change or benefits. The job that I took over has a completely different skill set than mine and I struggle to find joy in what I do. I've expressed this to my manager and they finally posted the position back in January. However, due to COVID-19, the position has been frozen and I'm back doing two roles still. I'm starting to feel unvalued, unappreciated and unmotivated. With no light at the end of the tunnel, I feel like I'm becoming a very transactional employee- something that I'm typically not.

At what point do I throw in the towel and have the difficult conversation with my manager about this?

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

18 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Terry Morris

    I know this stinks but at this time, I would say don't make any changes. You are lucky to have a job. Your company is not the only company that has a hiring freeze on. Once everything calms down, if they don't hire someone to take over the second position, then I would start looking.

    Don't forget the golden rule: it is easier to find a job when you have a job.

  2. Katie Warren

    I would say that you are not stuck there!! It is your life and career so while I don't recommend you jump ship right now, definitely start looking for jobs. You are not happy and I know how miserable it feels to sit at a job feeling like you have hit the ceiling and do not feel fulfilled. The power is in your hands so look at the positive- you do have a job bringing in money right now and you have some strong motivation to find a job and rock those interviews :) When you are motivated and passionate you show up better. Good luck!

  3. Shelby C

    It sounds like you've already had the conversation and it's fallen on deaf ears. If I asked one of my employees to take on another position, I would give them the larger salary and 50% of the lesser. It's only fair given the contribution that you're making to company, the additional skills, hours you've put in, etc. I've been there myself and I know it isn't simple.

    Terry said it best though. It's much easier to find a new position when you have one. You can start to look now, but this isn't the economic climate to leave a job.

  4. Terry Morris

    Hi Shelby, I wish you were my boss back in the day.

    More and more people are being asked to do more work, take on multiple roles without getting more pay. This was a reality before the COVID-19 environment and I bet it is only going to get worse.

    I personally would NOT start looking for a job just yet. Is it possible to move to another job within your organization?

  5. Shelby C

    You're too kind! I wish I was still in Corporate America; however, I'm a one woman show now. I write my own rules and only answer to two very bossy cats.

    When I couldn't give my employees the salary that they deserved, I always found other ways to compensate. When you're truly valued and it's a healthy environment, they will do everything they can to retain a good employee. It's the right thing to do and good business sense.

  6. HEATHER

    Hello Shelby,
    It's refreshing to hear an employer say what you just said. When the will is there on the part of an employer to appropriately compensate via salary or other ways, there will definitely be better staff retention.

  7. Shelby C

    Thank you! I spent the majority of my career in staffing and the smartest (and least expensive) thing you can do in the long run is to retain a good employee. The reality is that one good, satisfied employee will do the work of three. You only have to pay their benefits once, so why shouldn't you compensate them more? It is good business. It costs to train and you can't put a price on experience.

  8. HEATHER

    Shelby, I really like the way you do math:-) What a great formula to follow when an employee is doing the jobs of 2 people. You've provided a lovely nugget that others can use if they find themselves in the same situation in the future. I'm tucking your suggestion in my "salary negotiation" file:-) Thank you!

  9. Shelby C

    Thanks! I've used it myself many times, but as a general rule it is difficult to get more than a 25% increase at once. Exceptions can be made though. The way I have worked around it is by creating new positions. When you can justify the expense to the bottom line, the CEO usually falls in line. You need a plan. Everything needs to be justified. It also helps to have an advocate in upper management and on the BOD (unless you're on it). ?

  10. Jackie Ghedine

    I'm sorry you are feeling unfulfilled, I always say unhappiness at work spreads through our entire world.

    I don't think you should say anything else to your manager. Your were clear (for over 2 years) and they haven't made any changes to place you back in the position you were in.

    I would use this opportunity to start networking and exploring new positions that fit better. You don't owe them another conversation. If layoffs came down tomorrow, there wouldn't be loyalty to you.

  11. HEATHER

    Hello Anonymous,
    I agree with the comments above that 2 years is more than enough time for your manager to have made a change. My impression is that you are being taken advantage of here. I agree with my fellow FGB members who have encouraged you to start looking for opportunities that are a better fit elsewhere.

    You should be paid for the extra value you are bringing to the organization by taking on this extra work. It they weren't motivated to bring up your pay or change your title before Covid-19, I have difficulty believing they will be now, since many companies are suffering financially.

    I've also learned that even when some employers say "I'd love to give you a raise, but we have no extra money", that is not always absolutely true.

  12. Annetta Moses

    As a hiring manager who has sometimes taken 9 to 12 months to fill a role, I understand that it is a lot to take on the work of another position. Here are a few things to consider.
    Between the two roles, what is critical and what could potentially be eliminated. I had a role once in which I created weekly and monthly reports but noticed I only received questions on the monthly reports. I talked with my manager and she agreed that for 2 months I would create the weekly reports but not distribute them. If someone requested the weekly reports, I would continue to create them. But if no one asked about the reports, I could eliminate them and decrease my workload.
    Of the work that you are doing could any of it be given to another person in the company? I once spent a lot of time proofing documents. I eventually gave the proofing work to the receptionist.
    Do you need to continue to do the work in the same way? Are there things that can be changed to reduce the time required to complete tasks?
    I wish you the best.

  13. Jemm Thyme

    Same thing happened to me many years ago. I was promised after six months I would be "taken care of". Didn't happen. I finally quit after a year and many other things. My husband also worked there and my leaving was taken out on him. I could not go to a competitor as that would have gotten my husband fired.
    Sadly, I left the workforce and have been out almost 20 years. I have kept busy with a child and elderly parents. Volunteering as often as I could. I plan to somehow get a job after my child is driving in a few years.
    Looking back on what I went through, I would do a few things differently. First, I would become an expert at my extra duties instead of resenting them. It would have added to my skill set and looked great on a resume. Second, I would have gone and looked for a job instead of just resigning. If you quit without a plan and don't have something lined up...well it's not good for you mentally. Especially now, jobs are harder to find. My husband has been out of work since the beginning of December and he says that some job boards give information as to how many people have applied for a position. Before the pandemic, he said that it averaged 20 people per position and since the pandemic that number has risen to about 200 applicants per position.
    Learn as much as you can, don't complain (because it now will just sound like sour grapes), and as an old boss of mine used to say; "Keep your nose to the grindstone and your resume updated!"
    I sincerely wish you all the best!

  14. Anonymous

    I don't think it has to be a "difficult" conversation with your manager. "Where are we with unfreezing the replacement job req for xyz position?" is a very reasonable question to ask if it's been at least a month since the last time you got an update on it. Depending on the answer you get you can decide if you want to start looking for a new job or not. In today's environment I personally wouldn't want to quit a job without having a new one lined up, but YMMV.

  15. Joanna Poe

    It sounds like you've stuck it out for longer than is required. If they're suspending the new hire due to Covid-19, I'd ask why? Because they feel inadequate to the task of onboarding someone remotely, or because they feel that their business has been impacted to the point that they can no longer afford a staffing increase? If it's the former, that's not really an excuse anymore in our new world; plenty of companies are hiring and onboarding people remotely, and many have been doing it for a long time. If it's the latter, ask yourself how long that situation may drag out? It doesn't look like this is going to wrap up cleanly in just a few months.

    Unfortunately, the current situation does make things a lot more complicated. I would recommend searching for a new position before having the conversation, to leave yourself more options. If you cannot wait, for your own sanity's sake, then maybe have a talk with your manager about splitting this missing role's responsibilities up between members of your team, so it's not just you taking it on.

  16. Eric McRoy

    Your manager seemed to have gotten the point by posting this position, then reality struck us all!! Only you can determine what your destiny will be, many folks are just happy to be working, as you are.
    I know you are unhappy, however, since you've been performing essentially two jobs why not embellish those skills on your Resume'. When this Pandemic is over, then take a fresh look into your options.
    For now, try your best to content, for your family!!

  17. Catherine Leslie-Faye

    OK two things I would do. If a job is being offered that pays more look into it. And I would be talking with other members of my team to see who might take on part of the second job load so no one person on the team is doing two jobs. I'm hoping you are the only team member working two jobs for one jobs pay.

  18. Anonymous

    I have been in a very similar position for the last two and a half years. I have had the conversation with my boss - which turned into her yelling at and berating me and telling me that my disability accommodations are inconvenient for her. I was asking for *more* work because I am only given administrative duties but my job title is project coordinator. I have been waiting to slide into a different role, which I applied for in January and was told I would be moving into. Now that still-open role has been frozen due to a hiring freeze. It has reached the point where work became so stressful and I felt so undervalued that I became suicidally depressed. I am now looking into taking 12 weeks of FMLA since I have short term disability insurance because I don’t want to lose access to my job but, while I will continue to look for work, I am not hopeful of finding a job in this climate that pays close to my current pay rate with my benefits. I basically sold my soul/mental health for insurance and a pension. I guess my best advice is to keep looking but do not sacrifice your mental health for a a sh!tty boss.

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members