3 Mistakes I Made As A Manager That You Can Avoid | Fairygodboss
Mystery Woman
Tell us more for better jobs, advice
and connections
Don’t miss out on new opportunities.
Your feed isn’t personalized yet. Follow topics like career advice, lifestyle or health.
Discover and join groups with like-minded women who share your interests, profession, and lifestyle.
Get alerted when there are new employee reviews.
Get notified when new jobs are posted.
3 Mistakes I Made As A Manager That You Can Avoid
Adobe Stock / SolisImages
1 Comment

It was a sunny summer day when the CEO called me into his office: “Melissa,” he said, “I’ve had a complaint from someone on your team.” 

The world stopped at that moment. Wasn’t I the most fun boss ever? I organized BBQs at my house, cocktails after work, and crazy team building games. How could someone complain about me?

I didn’t realize that having good leadership skills is not just about fun team building activities, but a complex and often messy job that requires dedication to the growth and well-being of a diverse group of people — and adjusting your management style in the process.

I was good at leading the people who were like me: independent problem solvers who mostly managed themselves and came to me for approval or clarifications. But what about the people on the team who needed to be managed differently, with my attention on what they did well and where they needed guidance?

Diversity is important and requires effort from a leader. The people on my team who were just like me were happy with me as a manager. We had fun, we energized one another, and we enjoyed all the conversational shortcuts that let us make efficient decisions.

People leave bad bosses, not bad jobs. Some studies put that number as high as 70%.

The employee who complained about me left the company. It’s pretty awkward after you go around your boss to the CEO. I blamed myself for a bad hire, not mismanagement.

She made the tough choice to move on to another job. It pains me to think that I caused that turmoil. She was the one sitting at the bar, drinking with her friends and complaining about her terrible boss. Me.

You can be a better leader by using a few negotiation, persuasion, and influence techniques in your everyday agreements. Here are the biggest mistakes I made that you can avoid:

  • What you think: I thought that my job as a leader was to know everything. I needed to be like a benevolent ruler, doling out words of advice to a grateful tribe. I wasted a lot of time worrying that I was an imposter, thinking that everyone knew more than me and worrying that they’d soon find out just how clueless I was.

    No one knows everything alone, but your team knows a lot together.
  • What you say: I gave out advice like free candy in my early leadership days. I told people what to do and how to do it because it worked well for me. The beauty of a diverse team is that when you let people figure things out on their own, they often come up with better ways of doing things. Listen to you team, ask questions, get a feel for what’s happening before you say too much.

    Great leaders know that what you don’t say is important.
  • What you do: Leadership is not intuitive for most of us. I managed people the way my boss managed me, which was great for some people and horrible for others.

    I recently watched a leader carefully place each of his team members into the Situational Leadership quadrants so that he can guide them to success. 

    Get some leadership training for yourself.  

The bottom line

We know that 70% of people leave bad bosses, not bad jobs. The responsibility of people leadership is on your shoulders, to shape and guide the work you do every day for the next generation of leaders who look up to you.


Melissa Hereford will teach you how to Negotiate With Confidence. Get your free course Take the Fear Out of Negotiating at http://MelissaHereford.com
1 Comment
1 Comment

Looking for a new job?

Our employer partners are actively recruiting women! Update your profile today.

tag with leaves
The Fairygodboss Feed
We're a community of women sharing advice and asking questions
|Ask anything (even anonymously)…