Why do some recruiters do this? Ghost candidates even though they were the ones who reached out first.

Why do some recruiters do this? Ghost candidates even though they were the ones who reached out first.

I had one reach out to me on indeed saying I was perfect for a role they were working on. I replied I was interested and immediately they call me. I was at my desk and couldn't pick up. I told her this and she asked if we could set up a time that was more convenient. I said sure and never heard back. I even looked up the recruiting agency and called twice to leave a message. I never heard back.

Seriously.....

Why women love us:

  • Daily articles on career topics
  • Jobs at companies dedicated to hiring more women
  • Advice and support from an authentic community
  • Events that help you level up in your career
  • Free membership, always

Share your insight

Join an authentic community that helps women support each other at work. Share your professional experience or ask for advice — you can even post anonymously.

18 Comments

Join the conversation
  1. Coach Nancie Kay Shuman

    Unfortunately, it is a numbers game. In most cases, employers are working with multiple recruiters, thus it becomes imperitive that recruiters match candidates and employers as quickly as possible. If a candidate doesn't respond quickly enough, the recruiter moves on. This may also be, in part, because the employer has already closed the position.

    Now, is it rude that the recruiter doesn't reach out and say, thank you for your time, yada, yada, yada? Yes. But also understandable, as the volumn of contacts many make in order to make one connection can be overwhelming.

  2. Anonymous

    Its a numbers game. Out of 30 candidates, only 3 will be a perfect match when stacked against each other. So even though you were terrific, they found 3 that were perfect and those 3 get submitted. They are then on to the next open position. They don't waste time being professional and saying sorry no thank you. They only spend time earning $.

  3. Anonymous

    OP: But I didn't even have the chance to speak with them. I'm sorry but from a candidate's perspective, its rude.

  4. Anonymous

    In the recruiting world, being ghosted is standard procedure.

    Regardless of how "qualified" for a role you might be, at least 50% of the time, you will lose contact with your recruiter or interviewer for reasons that have nothing to do with you.

    Not only that, recruiters and hiring managers will respond defensively when called out on the practice of ghosting candidates that they don't have time to respond to every candidate. They will pick a very small percentage of the people they are in contact with and maintain contact with them, while completely ignoring all the others. At best, they will let AI and email auto-responders reply to candidates' attempts to reach out themselves, and they delete voicemails without responding.

  5. alex.wolf2

    Some recruiters reach out enthusiastically and then disappear because priorities change, roles get paused, hiring managers change direction, or they simply contact far more candidates than they can realistically manage. It’s frustrating, but it usually says more about their process than about you. For more, visit https://cleobetras.de/

  6. Anonymous

    OP: I get it but do things change after one day? I tried to call and message back on Indeed. I was very interested in the job too.

  7. Anonymous

    OP: I get it but do things change after one day? I tried to call and message back on Indeed. I was very interested in the job too.

  8. Megan Leasher

    I agree with all of the comments shared, but I want to add that it totally sucks for the candidate. You just feel rejected, yet not worthy enough to be actually rejected (just ghosted). Hang in there. The right role will be coming you way.

  9. OLIVIA JOHNSON

    Hi there!

    Great question!

    And it's with a heavy heart that I confess to being one of the culprits at one point or another throughout my career!

    As a fellow Recruiter, I actually said to myself that I would NEVER do this...but I have. It's not professional, at all and nothing makes it acceptable, but please know that in most cases it's not intentional. It just happens. The volume, the demand and the continuous communications can be challenging to manage. We're not just handling one or two job postings here and there like it may be perceived but for some 50+, 100+ for global orgs.

    I will say that being out the Recruiting game for a spell, I would probably handle this differently now especially with all the technology/AI available than before my hay day in the field BUT hindsight 20/20 AND easy to say when not in certain environments.

    So, here's a little article I wrote on what I call "the Recruiter Brain" and though this is not the time that most job seekers want to understand the other side, I think it can still be helpful and lend some relief in the process of assessing so that you know that it may have absolutely nothing to do with you.

    I also recommend taking a look at the comments that followed.

    https://fairygodboss.com/community-discussion/lyACK4oq1/reasons-why-you-may-have

    Hope this is helpful,

    Coach Olivia

  10. Anonymous

    OP: Yes but if a candidate is trying to contact you more than once, especially after you reached out first the decent thing to do is to call them back.

  11. Sana Nelson

    This is such a frustrating experience, especially when a recruiter initiates contact, describes someone as a strong match, and then suddenly stops responding. Professional communication should work both ways, and candidates deserve a clear update even when circumstances change. Ghosting can leave people wondering whether they did something wrong when the issue may have nothing to do with their qualifications. Discussions on career communities like Fairygodboss can be valuable because they give job seekers a place to share experiences, compare perspectives, and realize they are not alone. Open conversations about recruiter communication can also encourage companies and agencies to improve transparency and respect candidates’ time.

  12. Anonymous

    OP: I've lost count at how many times recruiters ghosted me these past few years. There's no excuse for it.

  13. Anonymous

    OP: I was at my desk at work when she called me. There was no way I could pick up.

  14. Anonymous

    YES!! This literally happened to me in the past month with three recruiters. 7/29 one recruiter told me they wanted me to do a shadow shift for a job. I did it and the hiring nurse stated they wanted to hire me and to check in with my recruiter. That same recruiter transferred me to another recruiter because "this was not their direct hire" or something. 2nd recruiter for the next 4 weeks kept ghosting me when it was time for us to the discuss details of the job. Last week was my final straw, and mind you got the personal number of the hiring manager and was letting them know what was going on. This past Wednesday I did a phone interview with another hiring manager for same company. Went in person for second interview. They told me I was "overqualified for the position" and wanted me to apply for a management position. ANOTHER recruiter wanted to set up an interview for today at 330CST. Guess who got ghosted again?!!!! lol It's been about a month and a half and I need a job. Luckily, I picked up some part-time work but it's depressing to keep getting ghosted.

  15. NONE

    I would like a chance to see if I can get anyone placed. I have business executive, truck driving, skilled craft, and positions at multiple law firms available.

    Email me your resume (and I will contact you with positions for a tailored cover letter as well as your authorization to work in the U.S.A. questions) to Dr.Shevron.F.McBride@gmail.com.

  16. Mitchell Jeff

    Recruiter ghosting can be especially frustrating when the recruiter was the one who contacted the candidate first. From a candidate’s perspective, it can feel confusing and disrespectful to receive an initial message, respond promptly, and then hear nothing afterward. There can be several reasons for this, including changes in hiring priorities, a position being paused, internal delays, or recruiters managing too many candidates at once. However, even when circumstances change, a short update would usually be much more professional than leaving someone without an answer. Clear communication helps protect the candidate’s time and maintains a positive impression of the company. Candidates also invest effort in preparing applications, responding to messages, and making themselves available for conversations. Overall, recruiters may have legitimate reasons for going silent, but consistent communication and transparency can make the hiring process more respectful and professional for everyone involved.

  17. Mitchell Jeff

    I think one of the most frustrating parts of recruiting is when a recruiter reaches out first, shows genuine interest, and then suddenly disappears without any explanation. Candidates often spend time preparing for calls, researching the company, and responding thoughtfully, only to receive complete silence afterward. I understand that recruiters may become busy, priorities can change, or a position may be put on hold, but a short update would still make a huge difference. Ghosting can make candidates question whether they did something wrong when the reality may have nothing to do with them. Professional communication should work both ways. If recruiters expect candidates to respond promptly and respectfully, candidates deserve the same courtesy. Even a simple message saying the role is paused or they decided to move forward with someone else is far better than leaving someone waiting indefinitely.

  18. Mitchell Jeff

    I think one of the most frustrating parts of recruiting is when a recruiter reaches out first, shows genuine interest, and then suddenly disappears without any explanation. Candidates often spend time preparing for calls, researching the company, and responding thoughtfully, only to receive complete silence afterward. I understand that recruiters may become busy, priorities can change, or a position may be put on hold, but a short update would still make a huge difference. Ghosting can make candidates question whether they did something wrong when the reality may have nothing to do with them. Professional communication should work both ways. If recruiters expect candidates to respond promptly and respectfully, candidates deserve the same courtesy. Even a simple message saying the role is paused or they decided to move forward with someone else is far better than leaving someone waiting indefinitely.

Browse recent posts

Fairygodboss VIP
Achieve your career goals.
Be part of the largest online career community for women to find jobs, advice, and support — for free.
Fairygodboss members